‘Love Your Enemies.’ Really? Really?

Tucker Carlson, Host of The Tucker Carlson Show, speaks during a rally for Republican presidential nominee and former U.S. President Donald Trump at Madison Square Garden, in New York, U.S., October 27, 2024. REUTERS/Andrew Kelly

Something terrible happened as I read Jason Zengerle’s Hated by All the Right People: Tucker Carlson and the Unraveling of the Conservative Mind. Some way through the searing biography of the conservative journalist, I remembered that Carlson is my enemy, that I’m a Christian, and that I have to love my enemies. And I quite enjoyed hating Tucker Carlson.

Don’t get me wrong: I oppose Carlson’s political convictions, his spineless selling out for fascism, his pompous style of mockery and contempt, and his failure to love his neighbor.

I picked up Zengerle’s book because of my own silly fascination with right-wing politics and because I find it grating that Tucker Carlson is an Episcopalian. I wondered if the book might shed some light onto his faith, and I didn’t have to wait long. The third page of the prologue tells us that Carlson met with President Donald Trump in 2020 to try to convince him to take the COVID-19 pandemic seriously because Carlson’s wife, Susie, told him it was his duty as an Episcopalian.

Tucker Carlson, the world’s worst Episcopalian

I’ve long joked that Tucker is the world’s worst Episcopalian. I’m sure someone could compete for that title, but it’s Carlson who drives me up a wall. I’ve never even been Episcopalian, but something about his inclusion in that denomination has always made me question the point of being so, well, inclusive.

I’ve been prone to wonder, “Shouldn’t someone have denied him communion at this point?” In my holier moments, I have deep theological convictions that drive this thought; at other times, I just feel bitter about belonging to the same ecumenical body.

Carlson became a serious Episcopalian in part because of his wife. Susie and Tucker went to St. George’s, the Rhode Island boarding school where Susie’s father was both headmaster and priest. A devout eldest daughter, her religious conviction seemed to sincerely compel Tucker toward faith. Zengerle writes that Tucker, despite his legendary talent for sneaking into her bedroom undetected, also began attending optional chapel services and joined an interdenominational ministry.

“[W]hat began as a sop to a girl he liked blossomed into a deep conviction,” Zengerle writes.

Carlson’s identity as an Episcopalian was formed in the more conservative wing of the church, before the split with the Anglican Church in North America. For a while, Carlson described himself as an “Episcopalian neo-con.” “I’m supportive of a vigorous foreign policy,” Carlson would explain. “I like Israel. And I’m conservative. I’m more socially conservative than I am economically conservative.”

When I spoke with Zengerle by phone for this review, he said that Carlson’s “Episcopalian” in that description was meant to communicate one thing: He isn’t Jewish. Given the presence of Jewish neoconservatives at The Weekly Standard where he worked, Carlson needed to clarify.

Before the unraveling

Zengerle’s narrative is a delight to read. It’s scathingly fair. The author describes, with some praise, Carlson’s obvious talents and hard work. Carlson changes his mind, evolves, and admits his perceived mistakes. He gets sober. He tries to balance work with family life. In short: He’s human.

In early chapters, Carlson is an ambitious writer at the Standard with a penchant for reporting and disregard for party loyalty. It’s almost admirable. Zengerle recounts the time Carlson received a book deal to promote “broken windows theory” and argue for more leeway for police. Once Carlson began to write the book, he found himself at odds with the central thesis. Though his second child was on the way, he canceled the book, returned the advance—$10,000—and offered a handwritten letter explaining himself. It’s an abnormal show of integrity for anyone. As the editor who received it told Zengerle: “It was the first and last time anything like that happened.”

Carlson loved writing, but his ambition brought him to television. He understood, as Zengerle recounts, the future of media and the chance to make a wider impact on the small screen rather than in shrinking publications. He also understood paying for his kids’ tuition. So, even though he reportedly held a low view of television journalism, he turned his efforts there.

Television widened the gap between the private-Carlson and the public pundit-Carlson. As he has more power to protect, more bad incentives, and more notoriety, his hypocrisy and greed grow more frequent.

Still, he’s not one-dimensional. He questions and then repudiates his support for the Iraq War, and grows angry with those on the Right who won’t. Despite his politics shifting from “neoconservative” to “paleoconservative” and beyond, he’s treated by D.C.’s elites, even the liberals, less as an abject enemy to avoid and more as a contrarian opponent worth engaging. Zengerle describes him as “the skunk invited to the political and media elite's garden party, to defy that consensus.” Tucker treats liberals the same.

READ MOREL ‘Love Thy Neighbor?’ Really? Is That All You Got?

Later, as his TV career at MSNBC is floundering, Carlson is cajoling audiences at the 2009 Conservative Political Action Conference, telling them that they need to invest in actual journalism, not demagogic commentary.

“The New York Times is a liberal paper, to its core it’s a liberal paper, but it's also a paper that cares about whether they spell people's names right, by and large,” Carlson says to a cascade of boos. “Conservatives need to mimic that in their own news organizations. They need to go out there and find what is happening, find actually what is going on, not just interpret things they hear in the mainstream media but gather the news themselves. That’s expensive. It’s difficult. And it is worth doing.”

I liked that argument. So, at the time, did Ta-Nehisi Coates. Carlson co-founded The Daily Caller and began hiring talented journalists to fulfill this vision.

But it was not long before The Daily Caller’s high-minded ideals gave way to promoting gutter racism. Carlson began chasing clicks, competing for influence, and measuring impact not by the effect on the lives of the public, but whether it earned him a link in The Drudge Report.

Carlson came to relish the backlash to his flamboyant bigotry too. As the Trump era began in earnest, Carlson stopped getting invited to be the skunk at the party, but he gained a host chair on Fox News. That fed both Carlson’s willingness to transgress and his glee in eschewing politeness and amiability. The more powerful his influence grew, the more transgressive he became.

‘When the world hates you…’

It would be easy to assume that Carlson has given up his Episcopalian identity as the church has grown more popularly liberal. Carlson reacted to Rev. Mariann Budde’s sermon calling for Trump to show mercy, by saying his church is “not a Christian organization at all.” It’s “pagan,” he said. But Carlson still calls it “my church,” “my bishop,” and says “we Episcopalians.”

As I followed the journey, I began to sit a little less comfortably with my own feelings toward Carlson. Hated by All the Right People gave me the distinct feeling that reveling in my own hate would only make me more like Carlson. At minimum, it wouldn’t make me more like Christ.

Worse, I saw how the pressures that molded Carlson existed in my own life too. I’ve got a kid and bills to pay, I’m embracing social media platforms (owned by oligarchs) as a way to reach the masses, and I have sat in meetings brainstorming ways to get more clicks on our website. If I’m honest, the line between brash self-confidence and relishing transgression can too often blur in my own heart; this isn’t a virtue.

Zengerle cover.png

The cover of Jason Zengerle’s Hated by All the Right People:Tucker Carlson and the Unraveling of the Conservative Mind. Courtesy Zando.

The worst of these realizations came as I came to the quote that became the book’s title. Carlson bestows it upon Hungary’s authoritarian then-Prime Minister Viktor Orbán and his compatriots. Orbán is “hated by all the right people,” and this, to Carlson, is proof that he is righteous.

It’s easy to justify ourselves with the same logic. For Christians, the temptation is in part fed by the gospel of John’s recording that Jesus says if the world hates his disciples, it’s because it hated him first. When the Right hates us, when fascists want to kill and deport our neighbors, when Carlson vilifies and mocks LGBTQ+ people, that feels like proof that we’re like Christ.

And maybe some of us are. But starting with hate inverts the gospel message. Christ says that we will be known as his not by who hates us, but by our love. “This is my commandment,” Jesus says before all that stuff about being hated, “that you love one another as I have loved you” (John 15:12).

Even if receiving hate were a fair measurement of Christlikeness, if Carlson and I both hate each other and are both Christians, who gets to claim we’re hated for Christ? In our haste to claim ourselves hated for Christ, might we forget that in the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus also says to love our enemies? This love was not purely spiritual or emotional, it was a material commitment of love, modeled all the way to the cross.

Reading Hated by All the Right People, I don’t think I developed much in the way of “empathy,” for Carlson. I find his actions and words despicable, and I will call him to repent and love his neighbor every chance I get. Inviting Holocaust denial and antisemitism, promoting racist conspiracy theories, and denigrating queer people are sins. 

Even with a clear trajectory, I didn’t find Carlson any more relatable by the end. I found him more confounding, confusing, and frustrating. Zengerle’s brilliant biography was a chance, though, to remind myself that Carlson is not an avatar. He’s a real-life person; he is my enemy, and I have to love him.

Loving my enemies is easier said than done. Some days, praying for my enemies is about all I can muster.

I start by praying for his health and his family. Just hoping that God is present for his needs and his loved ones. I pray he finds joy in their presence, their simple existence.

I continue by praying for myself. That I will be made more into the form of Christ and love my enemies. I pray for the stamina and the grace necessary to resist vengeance, to pursue life-giving politics and policies, to organize for even my enemy’s well-being.

I pray that Carlson feels the peace that comes from the presence of God, not from success or wealth or purpose or being hated by all the right people. As I say this prayer, I think about the presence of Christ that is offered to me and to Carlson each Sunday. I wonder if this means I don’t want anyone to deny Carlson communion. I’ll pray about that too.

Loving my enemies is easier said than done. Some days, praying for my enemies is about all I can muster.