collage of women and traditional feminine Christian imagery
Illustration by Vanessa Saba

When Happy Is Holy

Kristin Kobes Du Mez on Amish romance fiction and other products that shaped white evangelical women—and their politics.

AS A KID, I danced around my room to Amy Grant music on cassette tapes. My mom’s friend sold Mary Kay makeup. And I had a crush on the godly (read: hunky) pastor in Catherine Marshall’s novel Christy. Later I read Joshua Harris’ I Kissed Dating Goodbye and used babysitting money to buy Beth Moore’s Bible studies. I proudly wore a purity ring. Which is to say: The stuff Kristin Kobes Du Mez writes about in Live Laugh Love: The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made is the stuff of my evangelical girlhood.

To our detriment, many have treated the pink flowery merchandise in the “women’s section” of Christian bookstores as a curious sideshow, not a driver in the story of how evangelical Christianity in the U.S. has shaped our current political moment. But in Live Laugh Love, the highly curated marketplace of contemporary white Christian femininity is the main event.

As a cultural historian, Du Mez “focuses more on the lives of ordinary people,” she explained to me in an interview in September, “the communities that they participate in, the foods that they eat, the products that they buy, the clothes that they wear.” She uncovers who manufactured these products and ideas, and how they were sold, distributed, and marketed. She follows the money.

The result was, I’ll admit, unnerving. Live Laugh Love dusted off seemingly innocuous artifacts from my childhood—Little House on the Prairie, the life of Christian missionary Elisabeth Elliot, Pioneer Girls clubs, Thomas Kinkade paintings, Brio magazine, a constellation of contemporary Christian music stars—and fit them inside a narrative about politics and power that continues to unfold. “White Christian women often claim to be apolitical,” writes Du Mez. “They will tell you that their lives revolve around faith and family, yet what they think about faith and family informs their views on education, taxation, welfare, economic inequality, immigration, law enforcement, and what it means to be American.”

As with Du Mez’s 2020 bestseller Jesus and John Wayne: How White Evangelicals Corrupted a Faith and Fractured a Nation, her new book teases out the roots of white popular Christian culture. But now she’s leading readers from the 19th-century holiness (and happiness) preacher Hannah Whitall Smith to Erika Kirk standing next to her husband Charlie’s empty podcast chair in 2025 portraying him as a Christian martyr.

I talked to Du Mez about how this slice of religious history connects with rising Christian support for authoritarian and nationalist policies—and the cautionary tale it offers those working to counter these forces.

—Betsy Shirley, Sojourners editor in chief

collage of women and traditional feminine Christian imagery

Illustration by Vanessa Saba

Betsy Shirley: I grew up in Texas Bible churches and Midwest megachurches, yet I was still surprised by how strongly white evangelical women embraced Donald Trump in 2016. It felt out of sync with the Christian values of my youth. What did I miss about the culture that raised me?

Kristen Kobes Du Mez: That gets to the heart of my last two books: How can “good Christians”—who are often, on a personal level, lovely, kind, generous people—end up supporting arguably harmful policies, corrupt politicians, and effecting cruelty on a grand scale through their political choices? In 2016, the question was posed in terms of “How can white evangelicals betray their values to vote for a man like Donald Trump?” But historians don’t frame questions that way. Instead, we look at what the underlying values actually are: How [can] women who are taught to be sexually pure, self-sacrificing, loving, and kind support policies and politicians that do considerable harm—and not do it with any sense of betraying their faith, but really, consistently believing that they are acting out of their faith? That’s my work as a cultural historian: to examine how values are shaped, where they come from.

To understand today’s politics, you turned to Amish romance novels, among other things. Why?

As somebody trained in cultural history, I learned to take culture seriously. But also, as a Christian woman who has had one foot in this world and one foot firmly outside of it, I knew just how ubiquitous these products were, and how women—many women—encountered them. For example, the importance of women’s ministries in faith formation. Or reading their favorite Christian blogger over years. Or, frankly, listening to Christian radio five, six, seven, eight hours a day, every single day of the week. It baffles me that when we think of women’s spiritual formation, we don’t take these [cultural] things seriously.

Their true faith isn’t consumerism, but their faith is experienced and formed through consumer products.

You also take seriously the sincerity of these women’s beliefs, while at the same time pointing out when their “true faith” is in consumerism.

I would push back a little bit on that. Their true faith isn’t consumerism, but their faith is experienced and formed through consumer products. The faith, the beliefs are still very authentic. That’s why I spend so much time going back to the 19th century and talking about sanctification. What does it mean to become “holy”? Does one become “perfectly holy” or not? What does “total surrender” mean? And what happens when total surrender of one’s will to God morphs into total surrender to the authorities God has supposedly placed over you, which for women is always a man? Theology absolutely matters, but it’s much more complicated in terms of how people come to embrace the specific beliefs that constitute their faith. And that’s where these cultural products really play a role, especially when books are selling millions of copies. When you’re coming of age and you’re handed Josh Harris’ I Kissed Dating Goodbye, it doesn’t just teach you about sexual purity, as Josh defined it. It also teaches you about Christianity; it teaches you about holiness; it teaches you about God; it teaches you about good and evil, insiders and outsiders, and what is required of you.

There’s an irony there. Evangelicals themselves recognize the power of culture—but the fear was of how secular culture might shape you. I have very clear memories of being warned in middle-school Bible class about the danger of backmasking and satanic influence in rock music.

It makes sense that if you have a particular set of values, then you would want to surround yourself with sources of information that affirm and strengthen those values. That’s where Christian bookstores come in.

And, when you present all outside information as suspect—any guide to parenting, to sex inside marriage, to health and wellness, to “fill in the blank”—when everything that comes from the outside is suspect, dangerous even, it creates a very lucrative market for the products that are guaranteed “pure,” if you will. This is one of the ways that the Christian products industry grows into a multibillion-dollar business. It builds up this sense of “us versus them”: That we on the inside are pure and holy and that everything on the outside, or anything that questions us or our beliefs is necessarily “of the devil.”

Which is a Christian way of understanding the world, but I also bring Christian voices into the narrative that challenge this. I talk about Nadia Bolz-Weber saying this whole purity culture concept of “us versus them,” “pure versus impure” is unbiblical. She’s drawing on the Lutheran theology of the comprehensiveness of sin and of grace, that everyone is always, at the same time, 100% saint and sinner. So, theology matters: You can have a kind of holiness perfectionism that can fuel “us versus them” or you have an all-inclusive sense that, “Hey, we’re all fallen, and we all need expansive grace.”

You can experience immense power inside these spaces as long as you obey the rules—and there are many rules.

We’ve got to talk about Hannah Whitall Smith, author of the 1875 book The Christian’s Secret of a Happy Life. You show that her influence boomerangs through more than a century of white Christian women who embrace theologies of submission. What is Smith’s secret to a happy life?

The “secret” in Smith’s book is that when you align your will wholly with God’s will, then you will tap into the immense, unlimited power of the Spirit, the power of God, and that will flow through you and make you holy—like, completely holy, even perfect. When you are holy, you will also be happy. It’s the secret of the will. [As the hymn says] “Trust and obey, for there’s no other way to be happy in Jesus, but to trust and obey.” This is holiness theology. You can certainly find Bible verses that support this and, over time, it became the dominant version of evangelicalism in 20th century America; one of its offshoots is the Pentecostal and broader charismatic movement.

It comes with a promise of a blessing: If you do this, totally submit your will, your emotions, everything to God, you will be blessed with spiritual, and—it later gets added on—material prosperity. This theology is particularly attractive: It says that God will work in these ways, nothing mysterious about it. You can initiate it, and the blessing of all good things will be given to you if you follow these simple steps.

It is also a theology that is particularly susceptible to manipulation. This total submission of your will to God very easily morphs into total submission to the authority God has placed over you—and the authorities themselves will tell you who that is, and it will always be men over women.

And what would Smith think of what’s become of her book?

Oh my gosh, she would be horrified by what has been done with her teaching! She was a feminist throughout her entire life. Born a Quaker, then she embraced universalism. This whole “us-versus-them” use to which her work is being put, she rejected. She also tried so sincerely to live up to this ideal. She wrote that if you just follow these simple steps, God would bless you with holiness and happiness—and her life was miserable in many ways. Her husband cheated on her, her children died tragically. Later in life she had her own health issues; she realized the irony that people were using her book to believe, essentially, a lie. She ends up coming to terms with it by redefining happiness itself: I guess happiness isn’t an emotion. It’s not a feeling. It’s all about the will. That’s the only way she could make uneasy peace with it, but she conceded in her diary that it wasn’t a very satisfying answer. And so, she passes away, feminist to the end. She did not ever mistake submitting to God for submitting to her husband. And yet, this is exactly the use to which her theology would be put for the next century and a half.

collage of women and traditional feminine Christian imagery

Illustration by Vanessa Saba

It’s easy to assume that men are driving these theologies of patriarchy and submission—that white Christian women are victims trapped in a system. And there are cases where that’s true. But many Christian women also believe that their liberation comes through submission to a theological patriarchy. Why are these beliefs attractive to some women?

This is the formula that is handed to millions of Christian girls and women. Many women embrace it, because all of the religious authorities tell them that this is the way to be Christian, to be faithful.

In Live Laugh Love many of the women I write about are extremely capable and gifted. They find channels within which they can use their gifts, including many gifts that are not fully utilized within those prescribed roles. But what happens at the end of the day? One after another, women like Elisabeth Elliot, Anita Bryant, or Amy Grant run up against the limits of what is acceptable for women. You can experience immense power inside these spaces as long as you obey the rules—and there are many rules. To outsiders it seems like hypocrisy. You have women like Phyllis Schlafly or Dorothy Patterson who are preaching to other women: “You are a homemaker, that is your role.” Meanwhile, Patterson has a master’s degree and two PhDs, right? This whole system needs women proselytizing other women. It doesn’t work otherwise, and those who step into that role are given considerable power, as long as they continue to prop up the [patriarchal] theology, the ideology.

What kind of self-reflection do you hope your book will prompt for Christians who are not part of this evangelical culture?

First, I would say to people who don’t think that they’re part of this world, there’s a fairly good chance that you’ve been shaped by some of these underlying values, whether you realize it or not. I’m looking at evangelicalism as a consumer culture that is not restricted within denominational or national boundaries. Many mainline churches will be studying books published by evangelical publishers. If you go to a Christian radio station, it’s going to come packaged with these theologies, political ideologies, and cultural value systems.

That said, this isn’t a book just about evangelicalism. A parallel, secular thread of positive thinking operates in much the same way as this holiness theology: prioritizing a surrender of the will and then promising that all these good things are going to happen—must happen. Both of these strands mesh well with modern consumer culture. There’s always another product that will make things better.

We find ourselves in a dilemma: To reach millions of people with good ideas you need to go through this consumer capitalist system. That’s what works so brilliantly for evangelicals. Yes, they have a lot of powerful corporate funders—that’s not to be underestimated—but for the most part, you have people paying money for these products that are then shaping their value system in ways that align with corporate capitalism and conservative political values.

I have a quote from a Christian bookseller who talks about how if you try to change the values of your target market, good luck with that—you’re going to go out of business. What do we do with that when you need power to go up against a very powerful system? Maybe the teachings of Jesus are not compatible with a consumer capitalist system. And yet you have consumer capitalism working for more than a century to present a particular version of Christianity that is fully compatible with consumer capitalism and the consolidation of great power in the hands of a few.

This whole system needs women proselytizing other women.

What warnings does history offer for those who seek to counter dangerous ideas without replicating systems of harm?

Watch out for the tendency and temptation to dehumanize opponents. You cannot organize mass cruelty without first convincing ordinary people to dehumanize “the other.” I was highly sensitive to this when I was pulled into some conservative evangelical spaces: the language of dehumanization against feminists, Democrats, “apostates,” such as myself. I was called “a child of the devil.” Speaking as a historian, when you describe with such confidence fellow image-bearers as allied with the devil, as a threat to Christianity, then that moves us into dangerous territory.

For Christians, remember that every single person you are dealing with is an image-bearer of God. Remember that you are also wrong about a lot of things. Remain committed to a pluralist democracy. Stay human. Refuse to have your moral system reshaped by an ideology, even if that ideology seems to be what we need in this moment. Good people—genuinely loving, caring people—can end up doing great harm in the name of goodness and righteousness. And that does not apply only to conservative white evangelicals, if you think it applies to them. That should keep us all humble and extremely careful in what we say and do.

Many Christian retailers are not selling your book, but do sell tchotchkes stamped with “live, laugh, love.” If you could secretly implant a new slogan for candles, posters, and whitewashed signs in Christian bookstores, what would it be?

Great! Let me think. Well, this isn’t as pithy … Let’s see: “We all mess up. And we’re all messed up. So, love others and show grace.” That’s the throughline of this book: grace. At the end of the day, we all need that grace. If we’re holding ourselves up to an ideal of absolute perfection, or holding others up to that ideal, then they always fall short. That can leave all kinds of wreckage.

And for the believers: Genuinely look to Jesus, who knelt in the dirt and wrote in the sand, daring those without sin to cast the first stone.

Portrait of smiling woman cropped along the nose; a collage below evokes the cult of domesticity
This appears in the December 2026 issue of Sojourners

Betsy Shirley is the editor in chief of Sojourners.