The Common Good

Musings of a Millennial: Removing the Political Baggage from Evangelicalism

I am an evangelical.

But what does that label even mean anymore?

A few days ago I was sitting around chatting with a few new friends at my Bible college. One of them was a young Canadian and another was a middle-aged former U.S. soldier. We ended up on the topic of politics and how many companies and businesses in the United States give millions to political and social causes and somehow we ended up talking about McDonalds.

My USAF friend made the statement: “McDonalds is terrible because it gives millions to causes and organizations that you [speaking of me] directly oppose: LGBTQ rights campaigns, Planned Parenthood, etc.” I was taken aback because my new friend simply assumed that because everyone in this conversation was an evangelical meant that we all held a certain set of political ideals and social standards. For him — for millions of others — evangelical meant something far more than a theological persuasion. In the midst of this awkward moment, I decided to reveal my identity as a politically progressive/liberal evangelical, which automatically caused an immense amount of tension to arise in our conversation. How could I, a Bible-believing evangelical, possibly support the LGBTQ community’s right to marry? How could I think that Planned Parenthood was doing any good and that President Obama’s plan to rapidly decrease the numbers of abortions in the United States was progress in any way? Let’s just say that the conversation ended on a pretty tense note.

This encounter really caused me to re-reflect on the magnitude that the term evangelical has been hijacked by political and social agendas over the past decade and how a new generation of evangelicals is emerging that does not at all identify with any of the social and political baggage that has come to represent evangelical Christianity. Which brings me back to my original question: What does the label evangelical even mean anymore?

I can tell you this — it doesn’t mean that I am a Republican. It doesn’t mean that I am a Democrat. It doesn’t mean that I am pro- or anti-anything.

Evangelical, as a label, has absolutely nothing to do with political affiliation or social agendas. The term literally can be translated, “People of the Good News.” People of the Gospel. That is truly what an evangelical is — a person who believes that Jesus Christ is truly “good news of great joy for all people” (Luke 2:10)! An evangelical is someone who is committed to the message and methods of Jesus Christ — someone who thinks Jesus’ pronouncement that the Kingdom of God is in our midst is a statement of a growing reality, and that we have been commissioned by Jesus to go into the world and proclaim this Good News to everyone we encounter — from the halls of Capitol Hill to the projects of south Los Angeles.

My generation (the millennials) no longer identify with divisive partisan politics of our country done under the guise of “evangelicalism.” We have seen and heard the long and dirty history of evangelical politics. We are not only disenchanted with this “version” of our faith, but also disillusioned. Neither side seems to look at all like Jesus. Both sides of the evangelical political spectrum seem to have sold out Christ’s commitment to love our neighbor, our enemies, our God, and ourselves and turned radically inward, only desiring to further their own self-interests, no matter how noble or seemingly important they may be. We all know that both the political and religious structures in America are severely damaged. The millennial generation is optimistically working reform both. We envision an evangelicalism that is truly marked by a radical commitment to follow Jesus in every arena of living and to once again be people that live, breathe, and speaking good news of great joy for all people.

We also want to be politically engaged and don’t think that involves removing our faith from our politics, but rather allowing our faith to inform every area of our political engagement — not in an attempt to “bring America back to her Christian roots” or to legislate the Bible — but rather because we have come to believe that true discipleship requires us to seek to love our neighbors and work for the common good of all people. That requires us to be faithful stewards of our personal and corporate finances, but also to seek the good of those who find themselves below in poverty and provide health care to the least of these.

The fear is that this new generation will be theologically liberal. My friend, upon hearing my confession that I was a Democrat, initially began to run me through the theological ringer. My theology of the Bible was immediately called into question, and my friend was stunned to find that in general, our theologies were identical. It is simply a false understanding of millennials to think that we are nothing more than theological relativists. In fact, most millennials are returning to very traditional churches with very orthodox and traditional Christian theologies. It’s a direct response to the aloofness of decades of evangelicalism that moved away from deep theological tradition and truth to what became known as “seeker-sensitive,” which offered nothing more than an inspiritation exposition of some random Bible passage. We desire more than that. We desire a faith that isn’t, contemporary per se, but rooted. We need to know that we are a part of something bigger than ourselves. Most of us have very little desire to create “new” ideas about God; instead, we want a faith and a tradition that connects us both back toward our ancient lineage as Christians and moves freely forward — able to adapt and endure the ebbs and flows of our culture.  

As my generation rises to the positions of influence and leadership in the church and world, I believe we are motivated to work for the common good of all people, the good news that comes from and through following Jesus Christ. We are moving toward a more Christ-like mode of living, one that cares more for the person than their political persuasion or belief about certain issues. While we are going to be increasingly more difficult to nail down with a simple set of theological labels or political propositions, we are increasingly going to be passionate about looking like and living like Jesus — embodying the good news that he proclaimed. And that is incredibly good news.

I am an evangelical. No, that isn’t a political label. It’s my life orientation — centered on and motivated by the good news of Jesus Christ. Good news for my friends, my neighbors, my enemies, myself, and my God. May it be so.

Brandan Robertson is an aspiring writer, activist, public theologian and the dreamer behind the Revangelical Blog. He is currently finishing up a B.A. in Pastoral Ministry and Theology. He is a frequent blogger and podcaster at The Revangelical Blog and Podcast. To find out more, visit BrandanRobertson.com

Image: Excess baggage illustration, bezikus / Shutterstock.com

Sojourners relies on the support of readers like you to sustain our message and ministry.

Related Stories

Resources

Like what you're reading? Get Sojourners E-Mail updates!

Sojourners Comment Community Covenant

I will express myself with civility, courtesy, and respect for every member of the Sojourners online community, especially toward those with whom I disagree, even if I feel disrespected by them. (Romans 12:17-21)

I will express my disagreements with other community members' ideas without insulting, mocking, or slandering them personally. (Matthew 5:22)

I will not exaggerate others' beliefs nor make unfounded prejudicial assumptions based on labels, categories, or stereotypes. I will always extend the benefit of the doubt. (Ephesians 4:29)

I will hold others accountable by clicking "report" on comments that violate these principles, based not on what ideas are expressed but on how they're expressed. (2 Thessalonians 3:13-15)

I understand that comments reported as abusive are reviewed by Sojourners staff and are subject to removal. Repeat offenders will be blocked from making further comments. (Proverbs 18:7)