The Common Good

Republican Budget is an Immoral Document

Sojomail - August 2, 2012

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

Republican Budget is an Immoral Document

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners
Donate to Support Sojourners
Donate to support

Editor's Note: The following remarks were given on Capitol Hill on Aug. 1 as part of a call from faith leaders across the religious spectrum urging Congress to extend the Earned Income Tax Credit and Child Tax Credit for low- and moderate-income Americans. 

A budget is a moral document. That phrase was coined by the faith community and has become a refrain in the ongoing debates over deficits and budgets. But in this week’s House vote on extending the Bush-era tax cuts, we see one more example of the priorities and principles of the broader GOP budget and how they apply to the rich and to the poor. Because of this, we must conclude thatthe Republican budget is an immoral document — in the way it treats the poor. I certainly don’t believe that all our Republican lawmakers came to Washington to hurt poor people, but it’s time for some of them to challenge the dominant forces in their party and face the consequences of such indefensible choices.

We have a genuine hope for a long term bipartisan solution and, in particular, a moral non-partisan commitment to protect the poor and vulnerable from being expendable in these fiscal debates. We should also say that Democratic budgets have not been models of fiscal responsibility and social justice either. But what the House budget is calling for is morally objectionable on religious and biblical grounds — and people of faith from all political stripes should say so. In particular, to roll back tax credits for the poor to help fund tax breaks for the rich is morally reprehensible, and the faith community has to speak out.

Here is what the debate reveals from the highest moral lens: the House GOP budget wants to extend tax cuts and credits for the wealthiest people of our society while cutting tax benefits for the poorest — including millions of low-income working families with children at risk. Proven and effective tax credits, which can lift families out of poverty, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and the Child Tax Credit (CTC), which have historically had bipartisan support, are now being dramatically reduced. All the while, tax cuts for the wealthy are further expanded and the amount of money the richest can keep from their estate taxes continues to grow. This is an egregious contrast and a starkly immoral budget choice.

To reward the rich even more while actually punishing the poor is a direct offense to all of our religious traditions. For Catholic lawmakers, it is a fundamental violation of Catholic social teaching, and the Catholic bishops have said so. They called this budget choice “unwise” and “unjust.” Every Catholic lawmaker who votes for those misplaced priorities should be held accountable by their church. But that accountability can’t stop with Catholics.

The Bible confronts every Evangelical lawmaker with more than 2,000 verses that call us to defend the poor and vulnerable. If we say we believe the Bible, we simply can’t support policies that directly reward the rich and punish the poor: Christian lawmakers can’t keep going into their prayer breakfasts and leaving their Bibles at the door.

The Senate Democrats should be thanked for blocking these cuts and protecting tax credits for low-income families last week. But, to be honest, neither party has clearly and publically stated a fundamental principle that the poor and vulnerable should be protected. In these critically important deficit debates, that principle is crucial and must be central to policy decisions.

Reducing excessive deficits is a moral act, but also how we reduce them is a moral issue. It’s time for both parties to commit themselves to this principle: We will not reduce the deficit in ways that increase poverty and economic inequality. This is the fundamental principle of the Circle of Protection, a broad table of more than 60 church leaders and organizations across the theological and political spectrum committed to protecting the poor and vulnerable in these crucial fiscal decisions. We will continue to press and pressure the leadership of both parties to uphold that principle. Our nation has achieved bipartisan agreement to that principle in past deficit reduction, and we must do it again. This is a moral and religious imperative that we should hold all lawmakers to. And the Circle of Protection will do that on both sides of the aisle.

In all of our decisions, the poor and vulnerable — the ones Jesus called “the least of these” — should be protected, especially by people of faith, regardless of their party affiliations and political philosophies. It’s time to cut through all the political clutter, ideology, and self-interest. The Christian leaders of the Circle of Protection feel called by God in saying this to our political leaders: It’s time to do the right thing and protect the poor.

Jim Wallis is the author of Rediscovering Values: A Guide for Economic and Moral Recovery, and CEO of Sojourners.Follow Jim on Twitter @JimWallis.


E-mailE-mail this article to friends
FacebookShare this article on Facebook
CommentComment on this article on the God's Politics Blog


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

Gore Vidal and the Death of Refined Public Repartee
by Frank Schaeffer

When I learned of Gore Vidal's passing Wednesday, I recalled William F. Buckley talking to Dad and me about how Vidal and he used to go hammer-and-tongs arguing on TV — mostly on Buckley's program Firing Line — only to go have a drink together after the show. I often recall that conversation in the context of today's Right/Left cultural-political divide, and I can't picture any Fox News Channel host having a cocktail with any MSNBC host after they've disagreed repeatedly and pointedly in public (on separate shows of course). These days little clubs of like-minded thinkers pretty much exclusively seek out their own.
+ Click to continue

Science, Faith, and An Ongoing Conversation
by Tripp Hudgins

A century ago, students were engaged in harmonizing science and religion. A century ago! Friends, it always should be the work of religious people to make sence of science. Why? Well, because science is about discovering more and more about the world in which we live. To pretend that science doesn't exist is foolishness. Theology must take into account the world God loves. It's that simple. Theology has always done this and it (I hope) always will do this.
+ Click to continue

Women and the Olympic Gaze
by Julie Clawson

I have a love/hate relationship with the Olympics. I love the pageantry and global drama of it all. And even as one who hardly ever watches sports (I make exceptions for Roller Derby and Quidditch), I nevertheless find myself glued to the screen whenever the Olympics roll around. At the same time I am uneasy with the neo-colonial aspects of the Games and the fact that one's ability to win a medal increasingly depends upon how much money one's country has (making the Games a vivid illustration of global economic injustice). Yet even as I have watched (and enjoyed) the London Games with conflicted emotions, I find myself more and more uncomfortable with the ways the presentation of the Olympics serves to reinforce harmful assumptions about women in our culture.
+ Click to continue

What Religious Freedom Is — And Is Not
by Sandi Villarreal

Seeing those suffering abroad — seeing people still willing to die for their faith — puts things in perspective. It invites you to think before you invoke the religious freedom card. 

Think before you decide that the rights of an entire segment of the population should be subjected to a religious debate. (Read: Gay marriage should not be seen as an affront to your religious freedom.) Think before you start to use someone's out-of-context words for political posturing. I'm looking at you, mayors of the United States. Be careful before jumping on the "not-in-my-city" (mildly unconstitutional) bandwagon.  Think before you decide that religious freedom is only applicable to your religion — or that Muslims shouldn't have the same right as Christians to build their houses of worship.
+ Click to continue

Billy Graham: Punish America or Apologize to Sodom & Gomorrah
by Christian Piatt

Could it not be argued on as many bases that we're advancing in positive ways — even particularly with regard to affirmation of the rights of the marginalized — as we can for moral decline? Yes, pornography is a real problem, but what about our historic problems with sexual oppression and abuse? Is it really worse now than ever before?
+ Click to continue

Pro-Life or Pro-Choice? Many Are Saying Both
by Sandi Villarreal

How society self-identifies is changing. Most Americans no longer say they are solidly "pro-life" or "pro-choice" — rather they say both terms describe them well. While 71 percent of black Americans and 77 percent of Hispanic Americans say "pro-life" describes them well, 75 and 72 percent, respectively, also identify with the term "pro-choice."
+ Click to continue


Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Do you want a great resource to help you deliver a passionate sermon on justice and peace? Do you need lectionary reflections from a trusted source? – Learn More About Preaching the Word.

Common Prayer: A Liturgy for Ordinary Radicals. Now available in the SojoStore. Order your day with prayer and worship resources from around the world. Learn more.

Hundreds of evangelical leaders from across the theological and political spectrum have issued a call for a bipartisan solution to fix our broken immigration system. Sign your name in endorsing these principles.

Faith and Finance: Christians and the Economic Crisis. Sojourners discussion guide gives a faithful perspective on money, power, and stewardship. Great for Sunday school classes, small groups, sermon preparation. Download now.



Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.