An Open Letter to the Occupiers from a Veteran Troublemaker

"You know that their greed and violence have tried to silence your worships and frustrate your witnesses in church, schools, and hospitals. You have discovered that it is not the buildings that make a true church but the true foundations on which your lives are built." – Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams, denouncing attacks on the Zimbabwean church in a sermon to thousands of cheering Anglican members in Harare.

- (Source: Reuters)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail

An Open Letter to the Occupiers from a Veteran Troublemaker

Get a free issue of Sojourners Donate to support Sojourners

You have awakened the sleeping giant, too long dormant, but ever present, deep in the American democratic spirit. You have given voice and space to the unspoken feelings of countless others about something that has gone terribly wrong in our society. And you have sparked a flame from the embers of both frustration and hope that have been building, steadily, in the hearts of so many of us for quite some time.

Throughout history, often it has been left to the youth of a society to do that, and you boldly have stepped into the role of the emerging generation, which sometimes means saying and doing what others only think. You have articulated, loudly and clearly, the internal monologue of a nation.

Some of you have told me that you expected only to foment a short-lived protest and that you were as surprised by this "movement" as anyone else. Try to listen and learn from those whose feelings and participation you are evoking by encouraging more reflection than certainty.

While there are some among us who may misunderstand your motives and message, know that you are an inspiration to many more.

One of you told me in New York City last week, "This is not a protest, but a think tank." Another of your compatriots wanted me to understand that you are trying to build something in Liberty Square that you aspire to create for our global village -- a more cooperative society.

Most telling to me was the answer to the first question I asked of the first person I talked to at the Wall Street demonstrations. I inquired of one of the non-leaders who helped lead the first days of Occupation as to what most drew him to get involved in the demonstration and he replied, "I want to have children someday, and this is becoming a world not good for children."

My 13- and 8-year-old boys came to mind when I heard his answer, and I felt thankful. It is precisely those deepest, most authentic feelings and motivations that should preoccupy you, rather than how best to form and communicate superficial political rhetoric.

You are raising very basic questions about an economy that has become increasingly unfair, unstable, unsustainable, and unhappy for a growing number of people. Those same questions are being asked by many others at the bottom, the middle, and even some at the top of the economic pecking order.

There are ethics to be named here, and the transition from the pseudo-ethic of endless growth to the moral ethics of sustainability is a conversation occurring even now in our nation’s business schools (if, perhaps, secreted inside the official curriculum).

Keep pressing those values questions because they will move people more than a set of demands or policy suggestions. Those can and must come later.

And try not to demonize those you view as opponents, as good people can get trapped in bad systems and we've seen a lot of that. Still, you are right for saying that we all must be held accountable -- both systems and the individuals within them. It is imperative that we hear that message right now.

The new safe spaces you have created to ask fundamental questions, now in hundreds of locations around the country and the world, are helping to carve out fresh societal space to examine ourselves -- who we are, what we value most, and where we want to go from here.

Instead of simply attacking the establishment "economists," you can become the citizen economists, like the young economics major I met at the Wall Street occupation who discussed with me new approaches for society’s investment and innovation. We desperately need new vision like hers to come up with alternative ways of performing essential functions.

Keep asking what a just economy should look like and who it should be for. They are noble questions. But you’d do well to avoid Utopian dreaming about things that will never happen. Look instead at how we could do things differently, more responsibly, more equitably, and yes, more democratically.

Don’t be afraid to get practical and specific about how we can and must do things better than we have in recent years. One of our best moral economists, Amartya Sen, says that "being against the market is like being against conversation. It's a form of exchange." You have begun such a conversation about what markets could and should be. Keep talking.

Even in forums where business and political leaders meet, they too are asking those questions and using terms like "a moral economy" as a way to interrogate our present and failed practices. I’ve been in such a gathering this week -- just days apart from visiting yours -- where the participants slept on featherbedding in five star hotels rather than in pup tents on the sidewalk. And yet, surprisingly, they were asking many of the same questions you are.

Keep driving both the moral and practical questions about the economics of our local and global households, for that is what the discipline was supposed to be about in the first place.

I know you believe that the leadership on Wall Street, and Constitution and Pennsylvania avenues have all failed you. Indeed, they have failed us all. But while you feel betrayed by both our business and political leaders, don’t give up on leadership per se.

We need innovative leadership now more than ever. And you are providing some of it.

Think of stewards rather than masters of the universe as the model for leadership.

And remember, non-violence is not just a critical tactic but a necessary commitment to moral and civil discourse that can awaken the best in all of us. There is much to be angry about, but channeling that energy into creative, non-violent action is the only way to prevent dangerous cynicism and nihilism that also can be a human response to the injustice and marginalization many people now feel.

The anarchism of anger has never produced the change that the discipline and constructive program of non-violent movements has done again and again.

I remember what it feels like to see your movement as a lead story on the evening news every night, and the adrenaline rush that being able to muster 10,000 people in two hours time to march in protest against injustice and inhumanity can bring. I was in your shoes 40 years ago as a student leading demonstrations against the Vietnam War, racism, and nuclear proliferation.

I would advise you to cultivate humility more than overconfidence or self indulgence. This really is not about you. It's about the marginalized masses, the signs of the times, and the profound yearning for lasting change. Take that larger narrative more seriously than you take yourselves.

Finally, do not let go of your hope. Popular movements are the only force that truly brings about change in society. The established order is never as secure and impervious to change as those who preside over it believe it to be.

Remember that re-action is never as powerful as re-construction. And whatever you may think of organized religion, please keep in mind that change requires spiritual as well as political resources, and that invariably any new economy will be accompanied by a new (or very old) spirituality.

So I will say, may God bless you and keep you.

May God be gracious to you and give you -– and all of us -- peace.

	E-mail this article to friends
	Share this article on Facebook
	Comment on this article on the God's Politics Blog

+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

Say NO to the Pipeline
by Rose Marie Berger and Heather Wilson
On Oct. 7, the State Department held its final public hearings on the proposed U.S.-Canada pipeline, including testimony from various activists and faith leaders. A decision on the Keystone XL pipeline is expected from the Obama administration by the end of the year. Watch Sojourners Associate Editor Rose Marie Berger address hundreds gathered near Freedom Plaza in Washington, D.C.
+ Click to continue

Welcome to the Poverty Thunderdome
by Cathleen Falsani
Earlier this week, professional loudhailer Bill O'Reilly welcomed -- well, welcomed might be a bit generous -- radio and TV host Tavis Smiley and Princeton University professor Cornel West to his FoxNewsChannel show to yell at them....I mean, to interview the pair about poverty in America and the Occupy Wall Street demonstrations.
+ Click to continue

Alabama Immigration News Roundup
by Jack Palmer
Alabama Workers Skip Work to Protest Immigration Laws, Hey Alabama, Take A Hint From California, Alabama's immigration law prompts alarm, U.S. Seeks to Block Alabama Immigration Law, and many more reports.
+ Click to continue

Of Traffic and Tee Times: The Grace of Unexpected Community
by Caroline Langston
If we didn't leave the house right then, we were never going to get to my seven-year-old son's inaugural golf lesson at the East Potomac Park course, where a Washington, DC-wide "golf and leadership skills" enrichment program was set to take place in thirty-five minutes.
+ Click to continue

We Must Continue to Stand with Pastor Nadarkhani
by Jack Palmer
It is often easy to feel that we, as Christians in the West, face persecution from "the secularization of society." But at this moment, we should be far more concerned about those whose physical lives are put in real danger each day as they preach the gospel.
+ Click to continue

Adam Phillips answers, "What is an Evangelical?"
by Adam Phillips
This video is the latest installment in an ongoing series at God's Politics blog where we've asked leading clergy, writers, scholars, artists, activists and others who self-identify as "evangelical" to answer the question, "What is an Evangelical?"
+ Click to continue

Report from the Global Christian Forum in Indonesia: Day Four, Healing Memories
by God's Politics Editor
At day four of the Global Christian Forum, we heard the story of how those in the Lutheran World Federation this year publicly asked forgiveness from the Mennonite World Conference for wounds inflicted by their forbearers centuries ago. Unforgiven sin has a corrosive power, even over tens or hundreds of years. Forgiveness empowers and liberates those who have wronged one another.
+ Click to continue

Cold, Broken or Grumbled, Every Hallelujah Counts
by Caryn Dahlstrand Rivadeneira
Even though my heartbreak and disappointment were quite different than Amy Dickinson's (my marriage, thank God, was not ending), I couldn't imagine wanting to tell a soul. And yet, Dickinson -- a.k.a. "Ask Amy," the syndicated columnist who filled Ann Landers's wise shoes -- laments that she could not share her grief.
+ Click to continue

#OccupyWallStreet: Playing with Fire and Corraling the Golden Calf
by Anne Marie Roderick
In times of hopelessness and long periods of waiting for things to get better, will we let ourselves be cast into the all-consuming fires of idolatry? Or, will we stand up against the false gods and catch the flame of the Spirit in our hearts and minds? Our nation may very well be on the threshold of a crucial change. Who will you be standing with?
+ Click to continue

Jim Wallis on #OccupyWallStreet: "This Could Really Change Things" (Video)
by Cathleen Falsani
Last week, Sojourners CEO, the Rev. Jim Wallis, visited with #OccupyWallStreet demonstrators in New York City. "As I listen to them, I recognize what I felt as a young student-activist in the late '60s and early '70s," Wallis said. "I just feel from them what I felt a long time ago, that we're part of something much bigger than us, much larger than us...The visceral feeling [here] is, 'This could really change things.'"
+ Click to continue

#OccupyWallStreet: A Generation Finds Its Voice
by Tim King
Like many of my contemporaries, I found the non-violent protests in Egypt that led to regime change earlier this year terribly inspiring. But, also like many in my generation, I never thought such a movement could happen here.
+ Click to continue

Luci Shaw answers, "What is an Evangelical?"
by Luci Shaw
I wonder if the Lord God abhors labels as much as I do. Somehow we human beings need to group and categorize people according to their behaviors and the beliefs that seem to define them. I keep remembering our perceptions are not God's; God looks at the heart and knows us from inside out.
+ Click to continue

Moving South: Day Three at the Global Christian Forum in Indonesia
by Wes Granberg-Michaelson
When I first saw the Atlas of World Christianity, I was stunned. This massive work charts the changes in world Christianity over the past century, from 1910 to 2010. Numerous charts, maps, and graphs, along with 64 interpretive essays by scholars from around the globe tell the dramatic story of how the center of Christianity has moved to the global South.
+ Click to continue

Columbus Day, Wall Street, and Alabama Immigrants: “It’s About Power, Stupid”
by Debra Dean Murphy
In 1992, political strategist James Carville coined the catchphrase that won Bill Clinton the presidency: "It's the economy, stupid." Clinton made good on his word to address the deficit and high unemployment and through both skill and luck, presided over unprecedented economic growth and prosperity.
+ Click to continue

Naked Before the Lord: Unitarians Have More Fun
by Cathleen Falsani
A dozen men from First Parish, ages 64 to 87, got naked before the Lord (and everyone else, for that matter), for a fundraising calendar called "Celebration 2012."
+ Click to continue

Report from the Global Christian Forum in Indonesia: Day Two
by Wes Granberg-Michaelson
This is the second in a week-long series of reports from the Global Christian Forum in Manado, Indonesia filed by Wes Granberg-Michaelson, the former General Secretary of the Reformed Church in America. The Governor of North Sulawesi Province in Indonesia is a Christian, a unique feature in the country with the world's largest Muslim population.
+ Click to continue

The Spiritual Side of #OccupyWallStreet
by God's Politics Editor
As Occupy Wall Street protests head into a new week, religion journal writers are theorizing on the spiritual side of the movement.
+ Click to continue

Kevin Palau answers, "What is an Evangelical?"
by Kevin Palau
These large-scale, citywide, proclamation evangelism events have been a focus of the Palau ministry for years and continue to be a main component of our ministry model. But in 2008, we decided to try something new. In addition to proclaiming the good news, we wanted to demonstrate it. We began to approach evangelism with a truly holistic, word and deed model.

+ Click to continue

Crime, Forgiveness and Retributive Justice: A God's Politics Interview with Naseem Rakha
by Joshua Witchger
An eye for an eye, a life for a life. This is one way -- based, some argue, in scripture and biblical ethics -- that proponents of capital punishment justify the death penalty. Naseem Rakha, author of The Crying Tree sees justice differently. In this interview, Rakha tells stories from death row and the kind profound healing she has witnessed first hand between victims and perpetrators, and speaks at length about the power of forgiveness in action.
+ Click to continue

Afghanistan: A Decade of Life in the Midst of Conflict
by Heather Wilson
Ten years ago, as the United States went to war with Afghanistan, I passionately yearned for a way I could be part of a long-term developmental and peaceful response to the conflict. In 2003 I was finally able to move to Kabul -- the place I had been studying and dreaming of for so long.
+ Click to continue

Report from the Global Christian Forum in Manado, Indonesia.
by Wes Granberg-Michaelson
The most frequent question I was asked before flying to Manado, Indonesia was, "Why is the Global Christian Forum meeting there?" When the GCF committee began planning this second world gathering, we knew it should happen in the Global South, where Christianity is so resurgent.
+ Click to continue

Deadlines and the Death Penalty: The Case of Corey R. Maples
by Maurice Possley
The ink was barely dry on the death certificate for Troy Davis, executed by the state of Georgia on Sept. 21, when the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in an Alabama death penalty case that, if not for its serious nature, feels like a trip through Alice's looking glass. The question before the court is this: Should the state of Alabama execute a man who lost an opportunity to file an appeal in his case because a deadline was missed -- because of a foul up in a law firm's mail room?
+ Click to continue

Paradigm Shift
by Christopher Sofolo
A million thoughts are flittering about in our minds at any given moment. When we allow ourselves to hone in on one thought at a time we can embark on our contemplative mission. In a state of mindfulness we can begin to recognize how our perceptions have been formed and how to awaken to a deeper reality and thus a deeper compassion.
+ Click to continue

#OccupyWallStreet: Hand Gestures, Health Care and the Birth of a New Paradigm
by Tim King
Throughout the day here at the #OccupyWallStreet mass demonstrations in New York's financial district, you can find small and often somber groups meeting. They have agendas, a facilitator, a time keeper, and someone to keep track of the "stack" -- the list of people waiting to make a point or ask a question.
+ Click to continue

"The Arch" at 80: Saints Dance Among Us
by Adam Phillips
There is a magnificent, modern church mural at St. Gregory of Nyssa's Episcopal Church in San Francisco's Potrero Hill neighborhood that illustrates a kingdom of God that is expansive, welcoming, and full of dance. The only living saint dancing arm and arm with this beautiful, diverse, uncommon Great Cloud of Witnesses is the Archbishop Desmond Mpilo Tutu, the Nobel Peace Prize-winning Anglican archbishop emeritus of South Africa.
+ Click to continue

Lynne Hybels answers, "What is an Evangelical?"
by Lynne Hybels
I grew up in a form of Christianity in which "saving souls" was pretty much all that mattered. The God I discovered in that church was a harsh, demanding tyrant; I knew that if I wanted to earn God's love I would have to be very good, follow all the rules, and work very hard. Unfortunately, I worked a little too hard and eventually became utterly exhausted, seriously depressed, and physically sick.
+ Click to continue

#Occupy D.C., October 6, 2011
by Cathleen Falsani
See Sojourners' compilation of pictures and videos of Occupy D.C.
+ Click to continue

#OccupyWallStreet: The Faith Factor
by Cathleen Falsani
Slowly but surely, as media coverage of the #OccupyWallStreet demonstrations in New York and across the country continues to grow, attention is turning toward what the spiritual/religious/faith elements are to the larger political/social/cultural story.
+ Click to continue

#OccupyWallStreet: Bruce Came From Vermont...
by Tim King
Many protesters here have had some bad experiences with religion, but it's clear that they are genuinely open to seeing religion done differently. Another young woman summed it up nicely: "You work for a progressive Christian magazine? We could use a lot more of you!"
+ Click to continue

Lisa Sharon Harper answers, "What is an Evangelical?"
by Lisa Sharon Harper
Lisa Sharon Harper, Director of Mobilizing at Sojourners, answers "What is an evangelical?"
+ Click to continue

#OccupyWallStreet: "The First Time I Slept on the Street Was Seven Years Ago..."
by Tim King
The first time I slept on the streets was seven years ago. Last night in New York City, I slept on the street again, near the corner of Cedar Street and Trinity Place in "Liberty Park" with the Occupy Wall Street protesters.
+ Click to continue

+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" e-mail - the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Sojourners Among Those Occupying Wall Street
Christianity Today

"People’s frustrations, hurts, and feelings of being betrayed by our nation’s politicians and economic leaders are clear. They want to be heard," Sojourners' president Jim Wallis said.

Admitting that he does not know everything about the protesters and that some of them might not share his Christian views, Jim Wallis drew on the similarities between what he knew of the their goals and the goals of Christians who wish to enact social change through the teachings of Jesus.

“Being American is one of the worst bubbles” from which to develop a biblical perspective on politics, according to Jim Wallis. The CEO of the liberal Christian activist group called Sojourners explained that a correct interpretation of the Biblical politics is determined by life experiences.

“The way Jesus talks about it is very appropriate for any wealthy celebrity or businesspeople who are actors on the world stage: ‘Don’t make a performance out of doing something for someone else,’ ” says Cathleen Falsani, the web editor and director of new media for Sojourners.

Jim Wallis of Sojourners magazine says, “Cut references to the poor out of the Bible and you will have a book of holes.” Faith in politics is desperately needed. The trouble is, we are not getting it from Micah, Amos, Isaiah or Matthew 25, but from the obscenely wealthy corporations who hoard wealth, but don’t hire the poor.

"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way - whether favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: sojourners@sojo.net | Advertising: advertising@sojo.net | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.