The Common Good

Defining "Evangelicals" in an Election Year

Sojomail - September 29, 2011


“My faith teaches me to forgive, and I forgive them. But I cannot be accepting of their behavior. I cannot be victimized by hatred. So I have to move forward.” – Bishop Bryant Robinson Jr., pastor of the Macedonia Church of God in Christ in Springfield, Massachusetts, after a new church was built where the original building was destroyed by arson on the evening of election day in 2008.

- (Source: New York Times)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

Defining "Evangelicals" in an Election Year


Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners
Donate to Support Sojourners
Donate to support

Here we go again. Presidential elections are coming and the role of “the evangelicals” is predictably becoming a hot political story.

Ironically, voices on both the right and the left want to describe most or all evangelicals as zealous members of the ultra-conservative political base.

Why? Perhaps because some conservative Republicans want to claim a religious legitimacy and constituency for their ideological agenda, and some liberal writers seem hell-bent on portraying religious people as intellectually-flawed right-wing crazies with dangerous plans for the country.

Let me try to be clear as someone who is part of a faith community that is, once again, being misrepresented, manipulated, and maligned. Most people believe me to be a progressive political voice in America. And I am an evangelical Christian.

I believe in one God, the centrality and Lordship of God’s son Jesus Christ, the power of the Holy Spirit, the authority of the scriptures, the saving death of the crucified Christ and his bodily resurrection--not as a metaphor but a historical event. Yep, the whole nine yards.

I love my liberal church friends, but am more theologically conservative. I have many allies on the religious left, but I am not a member of it. I work closely with brothers and sisters of other faith traditions where we have common concerns, but I will never compromise the truth of my own faith.

I also collaborate with people of no religious affiliation at all, because I believe that religion has no monopoly on morality. But I also believe in evangelism, and have called and led people to faith in Jesus Christ. Like I said, I am an evangelical.

For me (and a growing number of others), it is precisely because we are Bible-believing and Jesus following evangelical Christians, that we have a fundamental commitment to social, economic, and racial justice, to be a good stewards of God’s creation, to be peacemakers in a world of conflict and war; and to be consistent advocates for human life and dignity wherever they are threatened. Because we are all made in the image of God. We are all God’s children.

And, because we are first members of the global body of Christ, before we are Americans, we don’t believe God blesses and loves our country more than others, and that the gospel doesn’t co-exist well with empires.

Millions of evangelicals are neither conservative Republicans, part of the Religious Right, nor members of the tea party, and they don’t believe that Christian “Dominionists” or any other religious group, should take over America -- despite what a rash of recent articles and commentaries have said.

Case in point: In the new book, Left, Right and Christ: Evangelical Faith in Politics, a hefty and provocative read that drops next week, Sojourners’ own Lisa Sharon Harper and co-author, The King’s College professor D.C. Innes, demonstrate that two authentically evangelical voices can hold very different views across a wide range of political, economic, and social issues. Many -- even most -- evangelicals don’t fit media stereotypes and are growing weary of hearing them repeated over and over again, especially from writers who know nothing about us, have an agenda to use or distort who we are and what we believe, or simply should know better.

After the election in 2004, I wrote a book the next year called God’s Politics: Why the Right Gets it Wrong and the Left Doesn’t Get It. Now in 2011, the Right still gets it wrong when they claim that most evangelicals are firmly in their base; and the Left still doesn’t get it when they tacitly agree with the Right’s claim that all the evangelicals essentially belong to the most conservative candidates. But the myth survives. Why? Perhaps because it’s in the interest of people on both sides to keep it going.

The Republicans have a longstanding strategy of using religion for their political purposes, while Democrats are just beginners at their own “faith outreach.” And some liberal writers -- many of whom live in the same zip codes in New York, Washington, D.C., and California -- seem all too eager to discredit religion as part of their perennial habit and practice.

On the one hand we have religious fundamentalists who are eager to use evangelicals, and on the other hand we have secular fundamentalists who want prove that evangelicals are stupid and dangerous extremists. But millions of evangelicals feel stuck and almost invisible in the middle of that political and cultural battle. One of the best responses to the recent articles about evangelicals came from Mark I. Pinsky, author of A Jew Among the Evangelicals: A Guide for the Perplexed and a self-professed “secular liberal,” who has covered evangelicals astutely for many years and counsels his fellow writers and commentators to take a deep breath and stick to the facts.

The facts do belie the stereotypes. Evangelicals run the political gamut from conservative and moderate to progressive and decidedly liberal. To suggest that most evangelicals reside on the far right is simply not true.

Younger evangelicals are more concerned than some of their parents with issues of social justice, human rights, environmental protection, and peace. Evangelicals in black and Hispanic churches tend to be more focused than many of their white co-religionists on economic and racial justice, and related issues such as immigration. Differences do exist between older and younger evangelicals, and between white and ethic evangelical churches. And the evangelical center has shifted significantly over the last decade.

Every journalist who wants to write intelligently about evangelicals should begin by reading the National Evangelical Association (NAE) landmark statement For the Health of the Nation: An Evangelical Call to Civic Responsibility, that spells out biblical commitments on poverty, the environment and climate change, immigration reform, war and peace, the protection of life, and the promotion of family, which should clearly dispel any notion that evangelicals as a monolith adhere to an ultra-right-wing political agenda. Rather, the NAE’s evangelical social and political ethic challenges all outposts along the political spectrum.

The untold story almost nobody covers is that global evangelicals have almost no affinity with America’s religious right or tea party. Even the math from election exit polls, challenge the political stereotypes.

In the 2008 election, Barack Obama won Indiana by 28,391 votes with 160,918 more white evangelicals voting for him than voted for John Kerry in 2004.

  • Obama had a 16-point swing among white evangelicals over Kerry, which clearly contributed to his victory in the state.
  • Michigan had an 8-point swing among white evangelicals while Colorado saw a 20-point swing.
  • Similar shifts in evangelical votes made crucial differences in other swing states such as North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Florida.

Democrats lost those gains in the 2010 election, proving that political shifts among evangelicals may never be permanent and that many religious voters may be voting more on issues of concern to them, rather than being loyal partisans and party members.

Isn’t that the way it should be?

In the future, evangelicals may likely vote more and more as independents, depending on the issues and the candidates, rather than according to any party loyalty.

It is precisely that kind of moral integrity -- in politics and any other arena -- that should re-define “evangelical” in this or any election.

Jim Wallis is the author of Rediscovering Values: A Guide for Economic and Moral Recovery, and CEO of Sojourners. He blogs at Follow Jim on Twitter @JimWallis.


E-mailE-mail this article to friends
FacebookShare this article on Facebook
CommentComment on this article on the God's Politics Blog


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

Kal Penn: Enough with the Cyncicism and Disappointment, Time to Re-engage!
by Kal Penn

But having had the honor to serve in this president's White House for two years, one thing that dissipated from my mind is the sense of cynicism that existed before.... But my reasons have to do with also having seen first-hand President Obama's strong convictions in action behind the scenes, and watching those convictions overcome partisan bickering to fulfill some really big promises.
+ Click to continue

50 Years of Peace Corps, 10 Years of War
by Mike Honda

As the Peace Corps celebrates its 50th anniversary this month, it is time to take stock and commit to making it bigger, better and bolder.
+ Click to continue

Generation XYZ: This Is Not Your Grandfather's Morality
by Danielle Tumminio

From being immersed in this supposedly amoral melting pot, here is what I've found: Brooks is right that many college-aged individuals do not have a traditional framework for tackling morality. Many are not immersed in religious traditions; few have taken ethics or philosophy courses. That said, they are far from impotent when it comes to discussing right and wrong.
+ Click to continue

The Republican Debates So Far (Part 2)
by Valerie Elverton Dixon

Recent history has proven that cutting taxes and regulations does not economic magic make. If that were the case, the United States' economy (and the world economy) would have gone into overdrive during the administration of President George W. Bush.
+ Click to continue

Church: Socks Are Optional but Grace is Required
by Cathleen Falsani

Too often, for too many of us, [church] is not safe, loving, welcoming, or full of grace. That's because church is a human institution and as faulted, imperfect and maddening as human beings themselves.
+ Click to continue

Heckler FAIL: To Obama, "You're the antichrist."
by God's Politics Editor

At a Monday night event in Los Angeles, President Obama was interrupted by a heckler. "Christian God is the one and only true living God, the creator of Heaven and the Universe!" the man shouted. "First of all, I agree. Jesus Christ is the Lord. I believe in that," Obama said, and then made sure the man hadn't left his jacket behind.
+ Click to continue

Life: Interrupted
by Vinita Hampton Wright

I've come to believe that one aspect of maturity is the ability to see life's interruptions not as interruptions but as necessary events and journeys. If we think of the unexpected as an interruption, then our attitude will be to get rid of it as fast as we can—so that we can get on with our "real" or "ordinary" life.
+ Click to continue

Western Christians Should Support a Palestinian Statehood
by Alex Awad

The majority of Christians and church leaders in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip support the Palestinian bid to seek full statehood at the United Nations. This position is not driven by anti-Israeli or anti-American sentiments but rather because most Arab Christians believe that without a resolution of the Arab-Israeli conflict they have no future in the Middle East, and without Palestinian statehood, there will be no end to the conflict.
+ Click to continue

Must-Read du Jour: Why the Antichrist Matters in U.S. Politics (NYT)
by God's Politics Editor

"The world in 2011 resembles the world of the 1930s in many respects. International turmoil and a prolonged economic downturn have fueled distrust of government, as has the rise of a new libertarianism represented in the explosive growth of the Tea Party." -- from Matthew Avery Sutton's Aimee Semple McPherson and the Resurrection of Christian America
+ Click to continue

Female Slavery in Our Own Back Yards
by Amy Stetzel

Despite the fact that slavery is now considered illegal in every country, there are more slaves right now than there has ever been in the history of the world. This reality does not exempt the "Land of the Free" as approximately 100,000 people are enslaved right here in the United States.
+ Click to continue

The Polemics of Forgiveness
by Tripp Hudgins

In the wake of Troy Davis' execution last week, social media was inundated with comments about our nation's justice system and whether or not it had, in the end, failed him. Not surprisingly, our nation's various polemics about the death penalty could be charted through the same comment threads. I don't have a problem with polemics in general. I think they are good for us. I would simply like to remind us that Jesus proclaimed his own polemic.
+ Click to continue

The Hard Cases
by Duane Shank

The same evening as Troy Davis was killed by the state of Georgia, Lawrence Brewer was killed by the state of Texas. Brewer, described as a "white supremacist" who was unquestionably guilty of a brutal hate killing, was hardly noticed. But if we are to be serious about opposing the death penalty, it is cases such as Brewer's that must also draw our attention.
+ Click to continue

R.E.M. Taught Me How to Lose Religion and Live a Life of Faith
by Adam Phillips

I think R.E.M. taught me foundational lessons in a life well lived -- in the public square, for others, and the good world around me.
+ Click to continue

The Republican Debates So Far (part 1)
by Valerie Elverton Dixon

As a liberal, a progressive that stands to the left of President Obama, I do not expect to hear much in a Republican presidential debate with which I will agree. The recent debates, however, have been eye-opening for the places where I agree with the candidates and places where I do not.
+ Click to continue

Somebody You Should Know: Christopher Sofolo
by Cathleen Falsani

Humanity has a primal desire to be part of a group, a club, a clique, etc., these desires are expressions of a deeper longing for community. Once a membership has been established with a religious institution this becomes your new identity.
+ Click to continue

How many slaves work for you?
by Cathleen Falsani

Through a new campaign, I was able to plug in some basic information about myself and my lifestyle... and in just a few minutes received the upsetting news that, according to the Slavery Footprint campaigns diagnostics, 52 slaves "work for me."
+ Click to continue

Voices from the Web (and World): Responses to the Troy Davis Execution
by God's Politics Editor

"Continuing a cycle of violence through state-sanctioned actions does not bring justice but only creates a culture of death and retribution. As a pro-life Christian, I believe the execution of Troy Davis shows a failure of moral leadership by both our country and the state of Georgia... Justice should restore and heal, not destroy." -- Sojourners CEO Jim Wallis statement today, Friday Sept. 23
+ Click to continue

Did Someone Say "Class Warfare"?
by God's Politics Editor

A few examples of the conversations being had about "class warfare" last week in Washington and beyond.
+ Click to continue


+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" e-mail - the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Tavis Smiley Tackles Poverty in America in a Weeklong Series on PBS' "Tavis Smiley" and on PRI's "The Tavis Smiley Show"
Sys-Con Media
Featured guests in this TV special series include: Jim Wallis, best-selling author, public theologian, speaker and international commentator on ethics and public life. He recently served on the President's Advisory Council on Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships and currently chairs the Global Agenda Council on Faith for the World Economic Forum. +Click to continue

Five Questions for The Circle of Protection
Values and Capitalism

This summer, as the launch of CASE reverberated throughout the blogosphere, Sojourners Communications Director Tim King and I agreed that we should build on the momentum of both groups, moving toward actually accomplishing something while demonstrating that Christians who disagree should stand as models of political engagement. So it was no surprise to me that The Post piece ends with a quote from Wallis in which he encourages our groups to continue to dialogue in ways that are “honest and specific, and, of course, civil.”

+Click to continue

Evangelicals Left and Right in October New York Forum
Publishers Weekly

Two evangelical Christian authors with divergent political views will discuss their new book, Left, Right & Christ: Evangelical Faith in Politics (Russell Media, Oct.) in a forum at James Chapel, Union Theological Seminary, 3041 Broadway (at 121st St.) in New York City on Thursday, October 6, at 7:00 p.m. Lisa Sharon Harper, director of mobilizing at Sojourners, a progressive evangelical organization that advocates social justice... A panel discussion will follow with Jim Wallis (God’s Politics), president and CEO of Sojourners...

+Click to continue

Why I Support Gay Marriage
Eureka Street
Scripture isn't a great deal of help in this area, though perhaps its relative silence is instructive. As the American Jim Wallis points out, there are 3000 references in the Bible to alleviating poverty, but very few on homosexuality. The Australian Christian Lobby's Jim Wallace acknowledges there is no place where Jesus taught one way or another about same sex marriage. +Click to continue


"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way - whether favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.


Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Free Gandhi poster with a new subscription to Sojourners magazine! Learn more.

Scared to talk politics in church? Get the conversation going in your small group with Sojourners’ discussion guides. Lots of topics and great talking points on challenging aspects of social justice. Learn more.

Wisdom for your commute: Download audio talks by Shane Claiborne, Brian McLaren, Lucy Winkett and more. Shop the SojoStore.

Order Strangers in the Land today, because greater justice leads to deeper faith. Take a six-week journey to get an in-depth look at immigration in relation to the church and the Bible. Click here.



Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.