The Common Good

It Takes a Movement: A Post-Election Analysis

Sojomail - November 4, 2010


"We are here to help people who have been the victim of an atrocious crime, whether it's police brutality or a church arson. If we don't do it, there's no one else who will."

- Cynthia M. Deitle, unit chief for the FBI's civil rights program, on why enforcing hate crime laws is a priority. (Source: Washington Post)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

It Takes a Movement: A Post-Election Analysis

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners
Donate to Support Sojourners
Donate to support

[Editor's Note: Today is the first installment of a six-part series by Jim Wallis reflecting on the past two years and painting a post-election vision for people of faith and Sojourners. We encourage you to read the essay, engage in conversation with others, and support Sojourners in making this vision happen.]

Inauguration Day 2009 was highlighted for our family by a visit from Dr. Vincent Harding, the eminent African-American historian, and a member of Martin Luther King Jr.'s inner circle during the Southern freedom movement. Despite health concerns and the dangerous weather, "Uncle Vincent," as my two young boys call him, traveled across the country to witness this moment of a history in which he had been so deeply involved. As we stood on the mall clutching our inauguration tickets in our mittens, Harding said, "It was a movement that started all this."

Do you remember how cold it was in Washington for the inauguration of President Barack Obama? Yet, it was one of the warmest days in memory: in the way two million people treated each other on the Mall, in the hope that filled the air around the country, in the sense of history being made with America's first black president, in the expectation that the country was about to move to a new place of change out of the grip of a deep recession, and the promise of a generational political shift. How ironically warm it seemed on that distant January day now stands in sharp contrast with the cold and very angry political atmosphere that was evidenced in the midterm elections.

In politics there is always a spiritual choice to be made -- to choose hope or fear. Leaders can build movements by appealing to a vision of what our country can be or by painting a picture of whom to blame and what to be afraid of. Obama won in November of 2008, in the midst of a recession, bank failures, and two wars, by capturing the political narrative which spoke to our values as a country and by riding a movement that had reason to hope and was ready to work for change. But the new president lost the narrative, and the "movement" is now on the other side of the political aisle. A strong values narrative attracted many in 2008, including many religious voters who had long eluded the Democrats. But now, many seem to have lost faith.

Contrary to conventional wisdom, President Barack Obama, a Democrat, reached farther out to the faith community than many Republicans have, including his predecessor George W. Bush -- both in his campaign and the first two years of his administration. While voters have often viewed Republicans as the party most friendly to religion, polling by Public Religion Research Institute showed that most viewed Obama and McCain as equally friendly to faith in that election. Indeed, highly energized and predominantly religious black voters overcame their cynicism to believe that another America might be possible, faith-inspired Hispanic voters dramatically shifted their allegiances, Evangelical and Catholic voters decided to break with their recent past (or their parents) because of what they heard from Obama. They were all drawn to a political leader who seemed to want to move past old political divisions and boundaries, and was not afraid to identify the moral issues at stake in politics.

But if you compare 2010 exit polls to 2006, Democrats performed 14 points worse with white Protestants, 14 points worse with white Evangelicals, and 20 points worse with Catholics. Compared to 2008, Democrats did 10 points worse with white Protestants, 14 points worse with white Evangelicals, and 20 points worse with Catholics. That is quite a swing vote.

Given many obstacles, administration advocates believe that Obama has a two-year record of great accomplishments, including some things that his predecessors failed to do. He thinks so too, and points to historic health care legislation, the most serious financial regulatory reform since the Great Depression, no energy bill but increased fuel standards, new student loan programs, unnoticed investments in infrastructure and clean energy, a much expanded national service agenda, and a plan for educational reform which we haven't seen in 30 years. Obama wonders why people don't see all that, which he calls "the most successful administration in generations in moving the progressive agenda forward." But Obama's legislative victories inside the beltway have clearly not connected to the everyday lives of too many Americans or to their core values. Many families who are struggling and afraid don't believe that Washington or Wall Street cares about them or is really with them. And they showed their anger at the polls, or their disillusionment by not even showing up.

Four years ago, and two years ago, people voted decisively for change; and now, in a shift no one could have predicted after the last election, voters have just voted for change again in 2010. And chilling polls show that the vast majority of the country, this time, voted against rather than for particular candidates or policies. The Republican leadership made it clear they were running a campaign that was meant as a referendum on Obama's first two years in office. The change promised in 2008 never came about in the minds of many across the political spectrum -- on the left, the right, and the center. The new president has been up against almost insurmountable odds, especially from all that he inherited, or as he puts it, the "cards we were dealt." But, from the results we just saw and the Republican priority of making Obama a one-term President, it clearly seems that many in the country would seem to disagree with the White House assessment. What happened?

[Part 2 of this series, "Why Politics is Frozen Solid," will be available on the God's Politics blog tomorrow. Sojourners is building a movement to inspire hope, over fear. That's the message that must echo in 2010. Help us make it happen.]

E-mail E-mail this article to friends
Facebook Share this article on Facebook
Comment Comment on this article on the God's Politics Blog

Building a Movement

Time for a New START: No More Nukes!

This past April, President Barack Obama and Russian President Dmitry Medvedev signed the New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (START). This treaty constitutes an agreement between both governments committing to reducing their long-range nuclear weapons arsenals by about one-third. New START is a significant step towards a world without nuclear weapons.

You can help make a difference by supporting the passage of New START.

+Ask your senator to support passage of the New START -- the right step toward nuclear non-proliferation and a world that honors the dignity and human rights of all people.

Inside Sojourners Magazine

The Christian Literary Underground

"Writers who want to let both their faith and their creativity run free are finding a new home in the Christian literary underground .... It's good news for everyone who eschews both cookie-cutter writing and cookie-cutter faith."

+Read more from Julie Polter's article, "The Borderlands of Publishing," in this month's Sojourners magazine.


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

Is Women's Leadership in the Church a Primary Issue?
by Mimi Haddad

If you are concerned about the question of gender and Christian faith you have probably heard someone say, "Yes, the woman's question is important, but it is not a 'primary issue.'"
+ Click to continue

Not Happy with the Results? Hallelujah, Anyhow
by Valerie Elverton Dixon

I am not happy with the results of the 2010 elections. I think the elections turned on misinformation, anger, and fear.
+ Click to continue

Political Games in Dead-Serious Times
by Debra Dean Murphy

Because Americans allow bickering politicians and ratings-driven news executives to tell us what constitutes "politics," we have a tragically short-sighted view of what it means to be citizens with a shared destiny who seek the common good and the flourishing of all.
+ Click to continue

After This Election, We Need a New Vision Forward
by Jim Wallis

This election, some good people were elected and other good people lost. Some of these officials, newly elected and re-elected, will try to find solutions to some of the great challenges facing our country today.
+ Click to continue

Do We Need Truth and Civility Past Election Day? Yes We Do.
by Elizabeth Denlinger Reaves

Well, we made it to Election Day -- time to pack up the ol' Truth and Civility campaign until the next election … right?
+ Click to continue

Stopping the Next Food Crisis
by Elizabeth Palmberg

Imagine a world in which Wall Street decided that vaccines were a good investment -- not pharmaceutical companies, but doses of medicine themselves.
+ Click to continue

Domestic Surveillance: FBI Spies on Catholic Workers
by Michael Komba

Since I moved into Casa Maria Catholic Worker in 1999, my work has focused around hospitality for the homeless.
+ Click to continue

Feed Her a Line: Bridging the Gender Digital Divide
by Carol Stewart

On a short trip to Jordan in 2001, I remember my amazement when tent-dwelling Bedouins taught me about text messaging.
+ Click to continue

Honor Roll: Senator Andrew Maynard and Republican Challenger Stuart Norman
by Duane Shank

A local Connecticut race for the state Senate seat has shown two candidates from opposing parties running a unique campaign of civility.
+ Click to continue

Moral Agency and Selective Conscientious Objection
by Logan Mehl-Laituri

Moral agency, simply stated, describes the ability one has to freely choose in accord with their morals. A moral agent is free, and freedom is the basis for all moral reasoning.
+ Click to continue

Things Worth Remembering from the Rally to Restore Sanity
by Sheldon C. Good

On my way back to Pennsylvania after attending Jon Stewart's Rally to Restore Sanity in Washington, D.C. last Saturday, I couldn't get one sign out of my head which read, "It's too bad we even need a rally to restore SANITY."
+ Click to continue

Jon Stewart's Misguided Rally to Restore Sanity
by Eric Stoner

While I regularly watch The Daily Show and think its political satire is second to none, the Rally to Restore Sanity that was held on the Mall in Washington, D.C. was problematic on many levels.
+ Click to continue

Friday Links Round Up: Van Gogh. SF Giants. All Saints' Day
by Jeannie Choi

Van Gogh. SF Giants. All Saints' Day. Here's a little round up of links from around the web you may have missed this week.
+ Click to continue

Stanley Hauerwas on Glenn Beck and More
by Jarrod McKenna

What do Cornel West, Rita Nakashima Brock, Carol Rose, and Onleilove Alston have in common? They are all our recent guests on Iconocast,a podcast "exploring the anti-imperial implications of Jesus' teachings within our modern imperial context."
+ Click to continue

A Hymn for Economic Justice: 'Zacchaeus was a Tax Man'
by Carolyn Winfrey Gillette

Many people grew up enjoying the song, "Zacchaeus was a wee little man," celebrating this beloved story of Jesus and a tax collector.
+ Click to continue

Churches and Elections: Do's and Don'ts
by Duane Shank

In the last few weeks, as seems to happen every election year, both parties along with some pastors and churches are stretching (or breaking) the legal limits on partisan electioneering.
+ Click to continue

Campaign Ads: Scarier Than Halloween Decorations?
by Evan Trowbridge

Around this time of year, I sometimes find myself wondering, "Is that a Halloween decoration or campaign paraphernalia?"
+ Click to continue

Honor Roll: Trinity United Methodist Church
by Patricia Kilby

When a radical, small Christian church threatened to burn copies of the Quaran on September 11, here in Gainesville, Florida, the international media descended upon our city.
+ Click to continue

Xenophobia 101
by Andrew Wainer

These can be frustrating times for immigration reform advocates. In spite of President Obama's pledges and a streak of national interest early this year due to Arizona's restrictive immigration law, momentum for policy change has waned.
+ Click to continue


+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" e-mail - the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Some say Democrats' weakened faith outreach partly to blame for losses Belief blog
Others in the progressive faith worlds, meanwhile, say Democrats - including President Barack Obama - have shied away from the faith-based messaging that they honed in the years after the 2004 election, which was seen to be determined by so-called values voters.
+Click to continue

Exit poll: God vote followed faithful pattern
USA Today Blog
Conservative Christian Jordon Sekulow can crow over election victories and progressive left Rev. Jim Wallis can lament the missing-in-action values like compassion for the poor in the vote. But now come the statistics and -- surprise -- the 2010 election was pretty much like 2008 and elections before it in the way people of faith voted. +Click to continue

Have Democrats Lost Faith In Faith-Based Outreach?
Religion News Service
But the Rev. Jim Wallis, a progressive evangelical who is close to Democratic leaders, said Tuesday’s election pointed to the party’s lack of vision, not networks.
+Click to continue

Consultants, columnists cite faith factor in Republican sweep
Associated Baptist Press

Voting Against
The Huffington Post

Is There a Politics of God?
Relevant Magazine

"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way - whether favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

NEW Wild Goose Festival: Early bird tickets are on sale now for a new summer gathering on justice, art, and spirituality! Modeled on the UK's Greenbelt Festival, Wild Goose will be June 23-26 in Shakori Hills, NC. Learn more.

Help Wanted: Are you a Sojourners reader who loves to sell? We’re looking for an enthusiastic, highly-organized Director of Ad Sales who can generate new business, close deals, and coach an ad sales team to success! Learn more.

Preaching the Word is Sojourners’ web-based Bible study and sermon prep service. Let leading voices on faith and social justice inspire you: Walter Brueggemann, Jim Wallis, Richard Rohr, Julie Polter, Ched Myers, Nadia Bolz-Weber, Paula Gooder, and more.

Get a Jump Start on Your Christmas List: Give a gift subscription to Sojourners magazine and get a free 2011 calendar.

God is not a Republican or a Democrat. Arm yourself with a political statement that makes sense. Get yours today!

Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.