The Common Good

The Immigration Fight Isn't Over

Sojomail - July 29, 2010


"They’re not giving the middle class a chance to live. Everything’s going up except our pay. They keep saying the economy is getting better. I don’t see it. I’m still making the same money I was 15 years ago. Probably less."

- John Slover, owner of Key Auto Parts in Edison, N.J., the city visited yesterday by President Obama. (Source: New York Times)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse email

Hearts & Minds, by Jennifer Kottler

The Immigration Fight Isn't Over

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners
Donate to Support Sojourners
Donate to support

[Editor's Note: Jim Wallis is on a well-deserved vacation for the next few weeks. Rev. Jennifer Kottler, director of policy and advocacy at Sojourners, will be writing the SojoMail column in his absence.]

Yesterday, U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton preliminarily struck down key provisions in Arizona’s infamous SB 1070 law and ruled that states cannot preempt federal law. While important, this is a victory that rings hollow for me and all those who care about the true reform of our immigration system. In many ways, the damage to neighborhoods and communities had already been done, as people did not wait to see how the law would affect them. Many mixed-status families pulled their children out of school and moved out of state, closing stores and restaurants and leaving many immigrant neighborhoods like ghost towns. This did not just affect undocumented immigrants but all those whose status might be called into question -- including citizens, permanent legal residents, and temporary visa holders.

The court’s preliminary decision is only the beginning of the litigation process, which will unfold in the coming months. Yesterday’s ruling, however, is a necessary first step in affirming the principle that it is the federal government’s responsibility to set immigration policy and to enforce that policy. It affirms that even if the federal system is failing, states do not have the authority to set or enforce their own policies.

Immigration is continually labeled as an issue that "deeply divides Americans." But is that true? Recent polling found widespread support for a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants. A new study sponsored by America’s Voice found that more than 75 percent of Americans who read a description of comprehensive immigration reform said they would support the measure. And according to Robert Jones, CEO of the Public Religion Research Institute, "More than 8-in-10 Americans -- including overwhelming majorities of white mainline Protestants, Catholics, and white evangelicals -- believe strongly that immigration reform should be guided by the values of protecting the dignity of every person and keeping families together, as well as by such values as promoting national security and ensuring fairness to taxpayers." There is a strong and growing consensus around much of what needs to be addressed by comprehensive reform.

It won’t be enough simply to enforce the laws we already have. While we are indeed a nation of laws, we are also a nation made up largely of immigrants and the progeny of immigrants. Moreover, we are a nation made up largely of Christians and people of other faiths -- faiths that teach and compel their followers to care about what happens to the other, and to honor the dignity of everyone created in the image of God. Granted, there is a vocal minority opposed to reform. And ironically, most -- if not all -- of the opponents are the children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren, or great-great-grandchildren of immigrants. Most of these people’s ancestors would not have been able to immigrate legally under our current system.

So now what? First of all, as November creeps closer, Bolton’s decision assures that comprehensive immigration reform as a moral issue will be front and center this election season. But as people of faith, we must reject the use of this issue to drive fear into the debate and pit citizen against citizen, and citizen against immigrant. We have to reject the politicization of this issue, and the use of immigrant families as tools to win (or make the other lose) an election. And when we see it happening, we need to call it out.

Secondly, it’s not enough to repeal the most controversial parts of SB 1070, as important as that is. The overall law still goes into effect today, which will lead to a confusing patchwork of guidelines on the ground in Arizona. This is a costly byproduct of enjoining the law, as law enforcement will have to haphazardly interpret the remaining provisions.

Therefore, lawmakers must act to fulfill their duty to make laws and set federal policy on immigration. It will take fewer politicians and more statesmen and stateswomen to reform our broken system. President Obama must lead on comprehensive immigration reform, and Congress must be willing to lead as well -- by having a fair and truthful debate on this issue and passing a bipartisan bill that will be good for our country. Clearly, the longer they wait, the more dysfunctional our system becomes.

Finally, each of us needs to be willing to lead on this issue. As difficult as it is to talk about issues like this with our friends and families, we have a responsibility to challenge falsehoods and myths about immigrants and talk about the contributions they make to our communities. We need to transform the rhetoric into truth. At the heart of our Christian tradition is the belief that true and lasting transformation is not only possible but necessary, and it can only happen when we are willing to do what needs to be done for the common good.

While I was at an interview yesterday about the Arizona law, I met a young woman. She asked me if I supported the Dream Act. (The Dream Act would allow students who graduate from college or go into the military the opportunity to become U.S. citizens.) I told her that we did, and she responded with thanks. She said a friend of hers just graduated from a prestigious East Coast university at the top of his class, but because he was undocumented, he is not able to get a professional job (despite his intellect and gifts) or go to graduate school. Instead, he is back home working in his family’s restaurant business, and our country and society lose out because we aren’t utilizing his gifts.

Also yesterday afternoon, children of immigrants -- mostly U.S. citizen children, many or most of whom live in mixed-status households -- held a march across from the White House to advocate for comprehensive immigration reform. These children live in fear of being separated from parents and family, many of whom came here for work they couldn’t find in their own countries. They came to provide for their families. They want what all parents want -- for their children to be healthy and fed.

Transformation is not easy. In truth, it’s very, very difficult. While we need the political will to transform our society, and leadership to get it done, we also need to be personally transformed, and we need to act as agents of transformation. If we fail to think and act differently, if we fail to change the way immigration is understood and debated in this country, we will fail our neighbors, our children, and our God. We have to choose to be transformed, and we have to choose to be active participants in the transformation of our society for good.

Rev. Jennifer Kottler is the Director of Policy and Advocacy at Sojourners. A long-time advocate for justice, Jennifer has served in advocacy ministry for more than seven years through her work at Protestants for the Common Good (Chicago, IL), the Let Justice Roll Living Wage Campaign, and the Chicago Jobs Council.

E-mail Email this article to friends
Facebook Share this article on Facebook
Comment Comment on this article on the God's Politics Blog

Inside Sojourners Magazine

Rolling for Jesus

Before breakfast on a snowy Friday, Philip Frabosilo preached in a booming voice to 30 men and women at St. Paul’s Soup Kitchen in Manhattan. Frabosilo, a large, mustachioed man in mismatched clothes, drives a yellow cab. But his passion is “Rolling for Jesus,” the one-man street ministry he operates from his taxi. “I minister day and night, feeding, singing, having fun with people, trying to move them away from traditional views if they’re dead-end views, and getting them involved with a real relationship with God,” Frabosilo told Sojourners in an in-cab interview.

+Read the rest of this fascinating profile in this month's Sojourners magazine.

Building a Movement

Gulf Prayer Service

This weekend, you are invited to join the Louisiana Interchurch Conference in a time of prayer for the recovery and restoration of the Gulf and its people. If you are able, you are welcome to attend the prayer service on Friday, July 30, at 7 p.m. If you are unable to attend this event, we encourage you to set aside a time of prayer in your congregational worship Friday, July 30th; Saturday, July 31st; or Sunday, August 1st to pray for the Recovery and Restoration of the Gulf and its people. This particular weekend marks roughly 100 days since the explosion of April 20. We also remember in our prayers those who lost their lives in the explosion and subsequent fire, and we pray for their families and all who grieve.

+You can find more information on the prayer service here.


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

'Hey Obama, Don't Deport My Momma!': A Photo Essay
by Heather Wilson

A children's rendition of Springsteen's 'Born in the USA' filled the air of Lafayette Square in Washington D.C. on Wednesday afternoon as U.S. citizens of undocumented parents gathered to urge President Obama to "keep his promise" regarding immigration reform.
+ Click to continue

World-Renowned Peacemaker Art Gish Dies
by Rose Marie Berger

Art and Peggy Gish are career peace, civil rights, and human rights activists who embody the motto of their primary affiliation, Christian Peacemaker Teams: "Getting in the way." Art died yesterday morning in a tractor accident on the organic farm where he and Peggy live near Athens, Ohio.
+ Click to continue

Key Provisions in SB1070 Struck Down
by Sheldon C. Good

U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton struck down key provisions in Arizona's infamous SB 1070 law today and ruled that states cannot preempt federal law.
+ Click to continue

A Step Towards Breaking the "Resource Curse"
by Elizabeth Palmberg

Here's a piece of good news you may have missed when President Obama signed financial regulatory reform into law last Wednesday: In addition to other good things, the bill will help grassroots activists worldwide hold their governments to account for the money they get from oil, gas, and mining corporations.
+ Click to continue

How Much Are We Willing to Sacrifice to Have Cheap Gasoline?
by James Lee Burke

The oil surge that is occurring at this moment along Louisiana's coast will kill thousands of square miles of living marsh. My father was a lifetime natural gas engineer.
+ Click to continue

Wikileaking Afghanistan: Disaster Is Not a Good Thing, But Knowing About It Is
by Nathan Schneider

The leak represents no less than a historic act of civil disobedience; consisting of 92,201 U.S. military internal records, this is the largest leak of classified material in history.
+ Click to continue

Darth Vader Goes Swimming and Clarity Floods In
by Tracey Bianchi

Then came this past Saturday morning when 7 inches of rain came down in less than 24 hours; when sewers backed up into my basement; when the local pool overflowed, all the major intersections in my community were submerged; and when I opened up the basement door to see my dear husband in his hip waders trying to get a pump to work.
+ Click to continue

Op-Eds Worth Reading
by Duane Shank

This morning, I found a trifecta of three of my favorite op-ed writers in the papers. The effect of the economy on families, the ongoing war, and the current state of journalism are all frequently on my mind.
+ Click to continue

Wikileaks, Truth Tellers, and a Crisis of Conscience
by Logan Laituri

Obviously, I'm not happy with the talking points being associated with the Wikileaks fiasco, and not just because I am intimately familiar with the charges of aiding the enemies of America.
+ Click to continue

Glenn Beck Co-opting the Steps of the Lincoln Memorial
by Ruth Hawley-Lowry

I am grieved and angry that Glenn Beck is going to be on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial on August 28 (the anniversary of the historic civil rights March on Washington on August 28, 1963) -- and I am not sure what to do about it.
+ Click to continue

Supporting Churches and Synagogues for Social Justice
by Simon Greer

When Glenn Beck urged his millions of viewers to "turn in their pastors" if their congregations promoted social justice, we at Jewish Funds for Justice decided enough was enough.
+ Click to continue

Scary Hope: The Nuclear Cinema of Summer 2010
by Tyler Wigg-Stevenson

Back in the late '90s, when Y2K fears were running rampant, apocalyptic fantasies like Armageddon and End of Days burned up the box office.
+ Click to continue

What Does Justice Look Like in Cambodia?
by Sheldon C. Good

For the first time, a senior Khmer Rouge commander has been found guilty of crimes against humanity in Cambodia, yet I'm left pondering how interpretations of justice vary across cultures.
+ Click to continue

Americans With Disabilities and the Church
by Julie Clawson

This month marks the 20th anniversary of the landmark Americans With Disabilities Act, signed into law by President George H.W. Bush on July 26, 1990.
+ Click to continue

Shirley Sherrod: A Moral Giant
by Chuck Collins

Shirley Sherrod is a moral giant compared to shameful media celebrities who wrongly accused her of racism. I met Shirley Sherrod in 1982, when I was 22 years old.
+ Click to continue

Inception: The Art of Paying Attention in Books and Film
by Debra Dean Murphy

Earlier this week I saw Christopher Nolan's new film Inception. In many ways it is the antithesis of Tinkers: an action-packed thriller with enough explosions, gunfire, and car chases to easily earn admission to the summer blockbuster boys' club.
+ Click to continue

History is on the Side of the Immigrant
by Andrew Wainer

"What part of illegal don't you understand?" This question -- usually launched by immigration restrictionists and aimed at immigration advocates -- is a good one.
+ Click to continue

Friday Links Round-Up
by Jeannie Choi

Christian jerks. An oil spill in China. A chance to take action. Here's a little round-up of links from the web you may have missed this week.
+ Click to continue

The Careful (and Necessary) Work of Journalism
by Duane Shank

This week, The Washington Post ran a three-part series on the top secret counterterrorism organizations and activities that have grown out of control since the events of 9/11.
+ Click to continue

The Tea Summit We All Should Attend
by Johnathan Smith

The NAACP recently roared into the national spotlight when, during the organization's 101st Annual Convention, its delegates unanimously passed a resolution calling on the Tea Party to "repudiate its racist elements and make it clear that there is no space in the organization for bigotry."
+ Click to continue

A Hymn of Welcome for Immigrants: 'Abraham Journeyed to a New Country'
by Carolyn Winfrey Gillette

Throughout the Bible, we see stories of immigrants -- people called to settle in new lands and begin new lives for a variety of reasons; people who trust in God's protection along the way.
+ Click to continue

How Heroes are Made: Remembering Nate Henn
by Jedidiah Jenkins

Heroes are not made in the warm hallways of cul-de-sac safety. Nor are they made of black and white print from the critic's air-conditioned desk. They are made on the tragic sidewalks of the world's lost promise, against the palace walls built on bones, and on rugby fields as a citizen of the world.
+ Click to continue


+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" email - the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Court dilutes Arizona migrant law
Al Jazeera
"We would love for the congressional delegation from Arizona, and the senators there, to support comprehensive immigration reform," Jennifer Kottler, a policy director at Sojourners, a Christian advocacy group, said. "That would address so many of the issues there." +Click to continue

Is the Tea Party unbiblical?
The Washington Post

Christianity's three camps: the essentials
The Vancouver Sun

Odds and Ends
Christianity Today blog

Disarmament battle needs faith community’s backing
The Chautauquan Daily

"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way - whether favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Wisdom for your commute: Download audio talks by Shane Claiborne, Brian McLaren, Lucy Winkett, and more. Shop the SojoStore.

Scared of being ‘left behind’? What does Revelation really teach us? Explore this question with Sojourners’ four-part study guide, Christians and the Apocalypse. Use it this Sunday with your small group - available online. Click here.

T-Shirts That Teach. Start a conversation everywhere you go with Sojourners' tees on faith and social justice. Click here for more information. Starting at $10.

Is God green? What does the Bible tell us about protecting the earth? Find out with Sojourners’ four-part study guide, Christians and the Environment. Learn more.

Let others know you're a Sojourner with this exclusive travel mug! With the Sojourners Logo on one side and a Jim Wallis quote on the other. Microwavable, dishwasher safe, and comes with a lid for commuting. Available here.

Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.