The Common Good

It's Time to End This War

Sojomail - July 1, 2010



QUOTE OF THE WEEK

"War appears inevitable. But, I continue to hope that the cloud will lift."

- Sen. Robert Byrd, in a speech delivered on the Senate floor on March 19, 2003, in opposition to the war in Iraq. Sen. Byrd passed away on Monday. (Source: Salon.com)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse email

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

It's Time to End This War

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners
Donate to Support Sojourners
Donate to support
Sojourners

After his unanimous approval by the Senate Armed Services Committee as the new Afghan war commander, General David Petraeus was pictured in The Washington Post with a broad smile and thumbs up proclaiming, “We are all firmly united in seeking to forge unity of effort.” No, we’re not, General. No, we’re not. In fact, I believe it’s time to begin to unite the religious community against the war in Afghanistan.

Following last week’s resignation of General Stanley McChrystal as commander of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, confirmation hearings began right away for Petraeus to become his replacement. But the real issue is not replacing one general with another because of inappropriate comments and insubordination -- it’s the fatally flawed war policy in Afghanistan.

In February 1968, North Vietnamese and Viet Cong attacks erupted throughout South Vietnam, showing that U.S. political and military leaders’ optimistic pronouncements that the end of the war was near were not true. By then, it was clear to many that the war was not winnable, yet more than half of U.S. casualties in Vietnam occurred from that spring until the end of the war (35,000 of the total 58,000).

I have walked the line at the Vietnam Memorial Wall many times, with tears running down my face as I read the names of my generation who were killed there. And the painful remorse over that awful war is even greater when I remember that the majority of those who died in Vietnam were killed after we knew we would ultimately have to come home without “winning” the unwinnable war. The last of the many reasons for staying in Vietnam that I recall President Nixon saying was to come home “with our heads held high.” We didn’t.

After 9/11, an international police action to bring the perpetrators of that horrible crime to justice would have been one thing. But to begin a war and then an occupation of Afghanistan was the wrong policy, quickly killing more Afghan innocents than the American innocents who died on September 11. It was then further compromised by the completely mistaken and morally unjustifiable war in Iraq.

When will we ever learn? The failed policies are all too familiar: a counter-insurgency strategy requiring more and more troops; creating the continued presence of a large U.S. military force; increasing the resentment and hostility of the Afghan people at a foreign occupation; trying to create a central government out of an ungovernable tribal society; and depending on an incompetent and utterly corrupt political ruler and regime.

An effective anti-terrorism policy was never really tried and was replaced by a “war on terrorism” which has failed. Here’s the metric: Has our primarily military policy in Afghanistan and Iraq killed more terrorists than it has recruited? I think we know the answer to that. The math of terrorism is against us. And our military obsession has made the most important question impossible to ask and even unpatriotic to consider: How might we reduce and defeat the causes of terrorism in the first place?

A new strategy in Afghanistan that focuses on humanitarian assistance and sustainable economic development, along with international policing, was also never tried. It could have been led by NGOs, both faith-based and secular, who have been in the region for years, have become quite indigenous, and are much more trusted by the people of these countries than are the U.S. military. But such assistance would have to be provided, as much as possible, by independent civilian and non-governmental organizations -- both international and local -- rather than using aid as a government adjunct to military operations.

Yes, after taking over the country, we do have a responsibility not to simply walk away. There are ethical and moral issues that need to be considered: legitimately protecting Americans from further terrorism; protecting the lives of U.S. servicemen and women; protecting the Afghan people from the collateral damage of war; defending women from the Taliban; genuinely supporting democracy; and of course, saving innocent lives from the collateral damage of war, to name a few.

And yes, effective development needs security. We could have focused on economic development, starting in areas that are secure and then growing to additional parts of the country, but providing only the security necessary to protect the rebuilding of the country. That kind of peacekeeping security would have been more likely to gain the international support we needed in Afghanistan, both from Europe and even from Arab and Muslim countries.

Non-military strategies should have led the way, rather than the other way around, as counter-insurgency doctrine requires. We should not have made aid and development weapons of war by tying them so closely to the military; rather, we should have only provided the security support needed for the development work to succeed -- led by respected, well-established international organizations with strong local connections.

The current strategy, even with a new commander, will only lead to more casualties -- U.S. and Afghan -- while likely strengthening popular support for the Taliban as an anti-occupation force. It is a strategy of endless war that is ultimately doomed to failure.

Last Sunday, the photo on the front page of The New York Times broke my heart. It showed the family of a military serviceman just before he was redeployed to Afghanistan. He was in his fatigues, holding his 6-month-old son with a look of deep pain on his face, with his wife resting her head against his shoulder. The article told story after story about families being separated by repeated deployments in an endless war. Soldiers who are fathers, mothers, sons, and daughters are dying for a wrong-headed, ineffective, failed, doomed, arrogant, theologically unjust, and yes, immoral war policy. And of course, the ones dying are not the young people headed for our best universities and successful professional careers, but rather they are the ones who have fewer options, or who see the military as their only option. Those with the least opportunities, and their families, are again the ones to sacrifice and suffer. It’s not right and it’s not fair.

The number of U.S. service members killed in June was the highest for one month since this now nine-year war began. It’s time to end this war. Or should we just start building another wall?

E-mail Email this article to friends
Facebook Share this article on Facebook
Comment Comment on this article on the God's Politics Blog


Building a Movement

Immigration and Your Church

Last week, hundreds joined in on “Faithful Perspectives: A Conversation on Immigration and Your Congregation” -- Sojourners' national teleconference on immigration, with Jim Wallis, Rev. Gabriel Salguero, Rev. Rich Nathan, and Angela Kelley. They discussed the tricky issues surrounding the debate, explored ways that pastors and church leaders could faithfully respond, and took questions afterward.

+ If you missed the call last week, you can download and listen to the audio here.



Inside Sojourners Magazine

The Persistence of Patriarchy

Hard to believe, but some churches are still talking about male headship. So what is the will of God for women today: silence or preaching, subjection or mutual submission? Many Christians in all denominations, including evangelicals, aren’t even asking this question any more -- yet the neo-patriarchal movement remains widespread. Read more about this neo-patriarchical movement in today's church and find a list of valuable resources.



ON THE GOD'S POLITICS BLOG

+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

On Arizona, Artists Speak Up, Refuse to Play
by Justin Fung

As a musician, I'm always interested in seeing how my fellow creative types respond to injustice or need. To raise awareness of human trafficking.
+ Click to continue

Obama to Speak on Immigration Reform Today
by Allison Johnson

President Obama is keeping hope alive for comprehensive immigration reform legislation this year.
+ Click to continue

Calling People to Faith
by Jim Wallis

I wanted to help clarify who we are in an effort for us all to put the main focus back on the mission of Lifest, which is to call people to faith in Jesus Christ.
+ Click to continue

The Moral of "Toy Story 3"
by Debra Dean Murphy

It's been awhile since Woody, Buzz, Jessie, and the gang have been on the big screen, but they've lost none of their charm in the interim.
+ Click to continue

Convenience and its Consequences
by Tracey Bianchi

All of this convenience comes with an added stress to our waste stream. It means we have baggies and Styrofoam, extra straws and single use microwaveable dishes.
+ Click to continue

An Open Letter to Madonna
by Cathleen Falsani

Dear Madonna, Thank you. Earlier this week, after a month-long sojourn in Malawi, my family arrived home in California with our newly adopted son, Vasco Fitzmaurice Mark David Possley.
+ Click to continue

Patriarchy in the Church and its Effects
by Sara VanScoy

When churches regard women as second-class citizens, they are espousing an ideology that is less than God's ideal!
+ Click to continue

Vandalism: A Dead-End Tactic at Toronto's G20
by Bryan Farrell

During Saturday's nonviolent protest of about 5,000 activists outside the conference center in downtown Toronto, where leaders of the G20 were meeting, several hundred masked figures dressed in black broke away from and started torching police cars and smashing store fronts.
+ Click to continue

Voices from the Gulf: Besieged by Depression
by Kelly Brotzman

One piece of the oil spill story that doesn't get told very much is the psychological piece. My partner, who grew up in beach communities on the Gulf Coast and has a deep emotional connection to these landscapes, has become extremely depressed as the oil spill has unfolded.
+ Click to continue

Robert Byrd, Truth, and Peace
by Valerie Elverton Dixon

Senator Robert Byrd was a man who had the courage to face the truth about himself and about his nation.
+ Click to continue

I'm a Mac, and I'm Helping Fuel War in the Congo
by Elizabeth Palmberg

But what Apple -- and Intel, Dell, Nintendo, HP, and other computer, phone, and other electronics manufacturers -- should be sorry for is their failure, so far, to do what it takes to make sure that their products don't contain conflict minerals from Congo.
+ Click to continue

The World Cup and Human Trafficking
by Julie Clawson

While human trafficking is common for any major event like the World Cup or the Olympics, the problem is seemingly worse in a country like South Africa.
+ Click to continue

Why I Remain a Catholic Priest, Despite Scandal
by Joseph Nangle

The Catholic Church is in perhaps its worst crisis ever. My first response is to ask forgiveness for the sins of my brother priests and bishops -- forgiveness from our Catholic people, the entire Christian church, other religious traditions, and society in general.
+ Click to continue

Durham Stands in Solidarity with Arizona Immigrants
by Chris Liu-Beers

Last week the City Council of Durham, NC voted to suspend city-funded travel to Arizona in response to the passage of SB 1070.
+ Click to continue

Adjusting to an Inter-racial Adoption
by Aaron Taylor

A few weeks ago I traveled to Ethiopia to pick up our adopted son, Isaac. Isaac was abandoned as a newborn infant and spent the first year and a half of his life in an orphanage.
+ Click to continue

Friday Links Round-Up
by Jeannie Choi

Here's a little round-up of links from the web you may have missed this week.
+ Click to continue

Wanted: A Strong Dose of Bipartisan Civility
by Sheldon C. Good

"How good and pleasant it is when the people of God live together in unity" (Psalm 133:1). Yes, and how ugly it is when we don't.
+ Click to continue

Wendell Berry Protests Coal's Influence in Kentucky
by Bryan Farrell

Renowned Kentucky farmer, poet, essayist, and environmental writer Wendell Berry is pulling many of his personal papers from the University of Kentucky's archives to protest the naming of a new campus building.
+ Click to continue

Beyond Camelot: Britain's Un-American Austerity Program
by LaVonne Neff

Our British cousins have come up with an economic policy that could not be more different from what we Americans have been doing for decades. I rather like it.
+ Click to continue




Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!






Big Oil Got You Mad? Get informed and activated for change with resources from Sojourners on Christians and the Environment. Learn more.

Wisdom for your commute: Download audio talks by Shane Claiborne, Brian McLaren, Lucy Winkett and more. Shop the SojoStore.

Scared of being ‘left behind’? What does Revelation really teach us? Explore this question with Sojourners’ four-part study guide, Christians and the Apocalypse. Use it this Sunday with your small group - available online. Click here.

An Award-Winning Magazine: Sojourners was recently named best general interest magazine by both the Associated Church Press and the Evangelical Press Association. Subscribe today!

T-Shirts That Teach. Start a conversation everywhere you go with Sojourners' tees on faith and social justice. Click here for more information. Starting at $10.






Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: sojourners@sojo.net | Advertising: advertising@sojo.net | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.