The Common Good

How Christian is Tea Party Libertarianism?

Sojomail - May 27, 2010



QUOTE OF THE WEEK

I’ve bled for my country, I’ve sweated for my country, I’ve cried myself to sleep for my country -- which is a lot more than some people who are passing judgment on me have done. I would rather go sit in prison than go to Iraq.

- Patrick Hart, U.S. Army sergeant with almost 10 years on active duty, who went to Canada rather than face a second deployment to Iraq. (Source: USA Today)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse email

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

How Christian is Tea Party Libertarianism?

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners
Donate to Support Sojourners
Donate to support
Sojourners

The insurgent Tea Party and its Libertarian philosophy is a political phenomenon, not a religious one. Like the Democratic and Republican parties it seeks to challenge, it is a secular movement, not a Christian one. As with both major political parties, people who regard themselves as Christians may be involved in, or sympathetic to, the new Tea Party; but that doesn’t make it “Christian.” But like the philosophies and policies of the major political parties, the Tea Party can legitimately be examined on the basis of Christian principles -- and it should be.

Since the Tea Party is getting such national attention, our God’s Politics blog is going to begin a dialogue on this question: Just how Christian is the Tea Party Movement -- and the Libertarian political philosophy that lies behind it? Let me start the dialogue here. And please join in.

Libertarianism is a political philosophy that holds individual rights as its supreme value and considers government the major obstacle. It tends to be liberal on cultural and moral issues and conservative on fiscal, economic, and foreign policy. This “just leave me alone and don’t spend my money” option is growing quickly in American life, as we have seen in the Tea Party movement. Libertarianism has been an undercurrent in the Republican Party for some time, and has been in the news lately due to the primary election win of Rand Paul as the Republican candidate for a Senate seat in Kentucky. Paul has spoken like a true Libertarian, as evidenced by some of his comments since that election last week.

He cited the Civil Rights Act as an example of government interference with the rights of private business. Paul told an interviewer that he would have tried to change the provision in the 1964 Civil Rights Act that made it illegal for private businesses to discriminate on the basis of race. He answered a specific question about desegregating lunch counters by countering, “Does the owner of the restaurant own his restaurant? Or does the government own his restaurant?”

A few days later, he spoke about the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. Referring to the Obama administration’s criticisms of BP, Paul said, “I think that sounds really un-American in his criticism of business.”

Is such a philosophy Christian? In several major aspects of biblical ethics, I would suggest that Libertarianism falls short.

1. The Libertarian enshrinement of individual choice is not the pre-eminent Christian virtue. Emphasizing individual rights at the expense of others violates the common good, a central Christian teaching and tradition. The Christian answer to the question “Are we our brother’s keeper?” is decidedly “Yes.” Jesus tells us that the greatest commandment is to love God and love our neighbor. Loving your neighbor is a better Christian response than telling your neighbor to leave you alone. Both compassion and social justice are fundamental Christian commitments, and while the Christian community is responsible for living out both, government is also held accountable to the requirements of justice and mercy. Both Christians on the Right and the Left have raised questions about Libertarian abandonment of the most vulnerable -- whether that means unborn lives or the poor.

Just look at the biblical prophets in their condemnation of injustice to the poor, and how they frequently follow those statements by requiring the king (the government) to act justly (a requirement that applied both to the kings of Israel and to foreign potentates). Jeremiah, speaking of King Josiah, said, “He defended the cause of the poor and needy, and so all went well" (Jeremiah 22:16). Amos instructs the courts (the government) to “Hate evil, love good; maintain justice in the courts” (Amos 5:15). The prophets hold kings, rulers, judges, and employers accountable to the demands of justice and mercy.

2. An anti-government ideology just isn’t biblical. In Romans 13, the apostle Paul (not the Kentucky Senate candidate) describes the role and vocation of government; in addition to the church, government also plays a role in God’s plan and purposes. Preserving the social order, punishing evil and rewarding good, and protecting the common good are all prescribed; we are even instructed to pay taxes for those purposes! Sorry, Tea Party. Of course, debating the size and role of government is always a fair and good discussion, and most of us would prefer smart and effective to “big” or “small” government.

Revelation 13 depicts the state as a totalitarian beast -- a metaphor for Rome, which was persecuting the Christians. This passage serves as a clear warning about the abuse of governmental power. But a power-hungry government is clearly an aberration and violation of the proper role of government in protecting its citizens and upholding the demands of fairness and justice. To disparage government per se -- to see government as the central problem in society -- is simply not a biblical position.

3. The Libertarians’ supreme confidence in the market is not consistent with a biblical view of human nature and sin. The exclusive focus on government as the central problem ignores the problems of other social sectors, and in particular, the market. When government regulation is the enemy, the market is set free to pursue its own self-interest without regard for public safety, the common good, and the protection of the environment -- which Christians regard as God’s creation. Libertarians seem to believe in the myth of the sinless market and that the self-interest of business owners or corporations will serve the interests of society; and if they don’t, it’s not government’s role to correct it.

But such theorizing ignores the practical issues that the public sector has to solve. Should big oil companies like BP simply be allowed to spew oil into the ocean? And is regulating them really un-American? Do we really want nobody to inspect our meat, make sure our kids’ toys are safe, or police the polluters to keep our air clean? Do we really want owners of restaurants and hotels to be able to decide whom they will or won’t serve, or should liquor store owners also be able to sell alcohol to our kids? Given the reality of sin in all human institutions, doesn’t a political process that provides both accountability and checks and balances make both theological and practical sense? C.S. Lewis once said that we need democracy not because people are essentially good, but because they often are not. Democratic accountability is essential to preventing the market from becoming a beast of corporate totalitarianism – just as it is essential for the government. And God’s priorities should determine ours, not the priorities of the Chamber of Commerce.

4. The Libertarian preference for the strong over the weak is decidedly un-Christian. “Leave me alone to make my own choices and spend my own money” is a political philosophy that puts those who need help at a real disadvantage. And those who need help are central to any Christian evaluation of political philosophy. “As you have done to the least of these,” says Jesus, “You have done to me.” And “Blessed are those who are just left alone” has still not made the list of Beatitudes. To anticipate the Libertarian response, let me just say that private charity is simply not enough to satisfy the demands of either fairness or justice, let alone compassion. When the system is designed to protect the privileges of the already strong and make the weak even more defenseless and vulnerable, something is wrong with the system.

5. Finally, I am just going to say it. There is something wrong with a political movement like the Tea Party which is almost all white. Does that mean every member of the Tea Party is racist? Likely not. But is an undercurrent of white resentment part of the Tea Party ethos, and would there even be a Tea Party if the president of the United States weren’t the first black man to occupy that office? It’s time we had some honest answers to that question. And as far as I can tell, Libertarianism has never been much of a multi-cultural movement. Need I say that racism -- overt, implied, or even subtle -- is not a Christian virtue.

So that should get us started. Let’s have the dialogue about how Christian the Tea Party Movement and its Libertarian philosophy really are. Jump in!

E-mail Email this article to friends
Facebook Share this article on Facebook
Comment Comment on this article on the God's Politics Blog


INSIDE SOJOURNERS MAGAZINE

The Art of Dying

Death is a human reality that eventually catches up with all of us. Scripture and Christian tradition remind us that we are living with death from the moment we are born. Through the Christian tradition of ars moriendi, or the art of dying, we are taught to die well by trusting in God, repenting for our failings, forgiving others, and having compassion for those whose needs exceed our own.

+Read the Sojourners magazine article "The Art of Dying," by Lisa Sowle Cahill, and find a list of resources on the topic.



ON THE GOD'S POLITICS BLOG

+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

The Song of Rosanna's Survivor Story
by Marcus Hummon

I heard Rosanna's story through tears -- hers and mine. She told me how she had been kidnapped, raped and beaten, brought first to Mexico, and later to the U.S. as a sex slave at the age of 14. She showed me the many cigarette burns, and spoke of the fear and intimidation ...
+ Click to continue

Why Do Americans Emphasize Charity Over Justice?
by Rose Marie Berger

Recently I came across "Walking in the Footsteps of Jesus: Catholic Social Teaching at Work Today" that's a great "cheat sheet" on Catholic Social Teaching and the biblical issues of charity and justice.
+ Click to continue

Hot, Humid, and Green Summer Ideas
by Tracey Bianchi

I wanted to nudge us all to thinking about these vacations in a wider global picture if we can. To consider trips and everyday summer days as a way to make a difference at home and around the world.
+ Click to continue

Poisoned Sea, Impoverished Soul: A Litany of Lament Over a Despoiled Ocean
by Ken Sehested

In the beginning, darkness covered the face of the deep. Then the Breath of Heaven swept across the waters, blessing the sea with all manner of creatures. The sea knows its Maker and roars its applause; the fish therein leap at the sound of God's voice. ...
+ Click to continue

What Rand Paul and I Have in Common
by Sheldon C. Good

Dr. Paul, a libertarian, advocates for the maximization of individual liberty. He doesn't understand what it means to be discriminated against, and neither do I.
+ Click to continue

Drugs, Guns, and Immigration: An Unholy Trinity of Failed Policy
by Ernesto Tinajero

There are problems south of the border. There are also causes north of border as well. The contributing reasons include our failed immigration, drug, and gun policies.
+ Click to continue

Climate of Change: Global Grassroots Environmental Success Stories
by Becky Garrison

In Climate of Change, director Brian Hill tells the story of how ordinary people from around the world are taking action steps to save the environment. I caught up with Brian at a press roundtable held during the Tribeca Film Festival.
+ Click to continue

Growing Where We're Planted
by Tony Campolo

Seldom do any of us stay in one place long enough to connect with what is happening in any one neighborhood or village. Moving is a big deal, even though we are prone to ignore its ability to negate the lasting impact that can be made if one stays put.
+ Click to continue

A Matter of Integrity: Richard Blumenthal's Vietnam Controversy
by Duane Shank

Richard Blumenthal, Connecticut attorney general and Senate candidate, got himself into hot water last week when news accounts reported that he has been saying he served in Vietnam. It turns out he was in the Marine Corps Reserve during Vietnam, but was not in Vietnam.
+ Click to continue

BP's Betrayal of Its 'Beyond Petroleum' Branding
by Margaret Benefiel

As BP's oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico worsens by the day, the world's eyes are on the self-proclaimed "green" company. When former CEO Lord Browne announced that BP henceforth stood for "Beyond Petroleum," he emphasized that BP took seriously its identity as an energy company, not just an oil company.
+ Click to continue

Bill McKibben's Brave New Eaarth (No, That's Not a Typo)
by LaVonne Neff

Yes, there are supposed to be two a's in Eaarth -- McKibben's point is that over the last four decades, "the earth has changed in profound ways, ways that have already taken us out of the sweet spot where humans so long thrived." It is so different, in fact, that "it needs a new name." And we Eaarthlings are in such denial about the differences that we probably need a global AA-style intervention, though McKibben nowhere suggests that the double-A is a pun.
+ Click to continue

Further Reflections on the Biblical Ruth as an 'Illegal Immigrant'
by Aaron Taylor

In March, I wrote a piece praising the Biblical character Boaz for showing compassion to Ruth, whom I referred to in the article as an "illegal immigrant." Ruth, as you may know, was a descendant of Moab and according to the law at the time was supposed to be excluded from the congregation of Israel.
+ Click to continue

Video: Jim Wallis Talks About the Oil Spill with Chris Matthews
by Jim Wallis

100524-jim-wallis-hardball-oil-spill
+ Click to watch

Scope of Oil Spill and BP's Bungling Demand Greater Government Action
by Allie Bullard

The government must get involved and care for needs of the Gulf Coast communities whose very lives are in hands of BP. By no means is BP the only bad actor, but the reality is right now they are getting to control how the clean up and recovery process is working.
+ Click to continue

Pentecost's Pente-chaos: Nothing's Changed
by Nadia Bolz-Weber

All the Christian archetypes were already in place on the very first day. The story opens with that small group of believers isolating themselves all together in one place ?Like in John's gospel when they were all gathered behind locked doors, as the text says, for fear.
+ Click to continue

Immigration Activism: 'Take Our Small Actions and Multiply Them'
by Lisa Sharon Harper

Last Monday I got arrested. Now, you've got to understand, I'm the kind of person who cried my eyes out in fifth grade when I got a pink slip for lateness from Miss Roosevelt. But I got arrested last Monday...and it was worth it. In the shadow of Arizona's immoral immigration law, I locked arms with 15 other faith leaders, labor union leaders, and two city councilmen.
+ Click to continue

Finance Reform a Historic Accomplishment
by Jim Wallis

Because of the excesses that led to the current Great Recession, in which millions of Americans lost their homes and jobs, the pendulum has once again swung from an era of an "anything goes" mentality to more careful public oversight and government regulation.
+ Click to continue

Cosmic Child Abuse?: Mark Driscoll, N.T. Wright and Atonement that does Jesus Justice
by Jarrod McKenna

It's clear that Driscoll is desperate to affirm the scandal of the cross in a sea of self-help-Oprahesque-pop-psychology-blab-and-grab-"Christianity" that airbrushes the horror of the cross out and replaces it with what Ched Myers would called "sugar coated easy-believism." But is what Driscoll articulates as the "scandal" of the gospel (that "God hates you," "God is angry" etc.) the same scandal that the apostle Paul refers to when he says, "but we preach Christ crucified?"

+ Click to continue

Christian Anti-Logic and Immigration Reform
by Valerie Elverton Dixon

Christianity is a counter-intuitive religion. The ethics of Jesus requires a rationality that is antithetical to ordinary logic. When ordinary logic says if someone hits you, hit them back, the anti-logic of Jesus says turn the other cheek. On the question of illegal immigration, Christian anti-logic says to solve the problem, make it easier for people to come legally into the country to work.
+ Click to continue

SOJOURNERS IN THE NEWS

+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" e-mail - the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Glenn Beck says Obama uses churches on climate change
USA Today Greenhouse Blog
"The faith community is pushing the government, rather than the government using us," writes Jim Wallis on The Huffington Post, in response to Beck's remarks. +Click to continue


Wallis responds to Beck’s attack on churches and climate change
Media Matters
Beck upped the ante, declaring that through recommendations issued by a faith-based advisory council (of which Wallis is a member) that included bringing churches “to the fight of climate change by greening buildings and promoting environmental stewardship in their congregations,” the Obama administration will be "literally merging ... your church with the EPA." +Click to continue


Glenn Beck's Gospel
Christianity Today blog
In March, Beck received national attention for his attacks on churches that promote social justice and on Sojourners president Jim Wallis. +Click to continue


Beck bears false witness to boost conspiracy that progressives want to "poison" churches
Media Matters
Purporting to provide evidence that progressives are trying to "poison" churches with a "radical perversion of the gospel," Glenn Beck recycled distortions of remarks made by Rev. Jim Wallis and Al Gore in order to paint them as Marxists. +Click to continue


Study explores how nonviolence is more effective than violence
Ekklesia (United Kingdom)

"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way - whether favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.




Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!






Big Oil Got You Mad? Get informed and activated for change with resources from Sojourners on Christians and the Environment. Learn more.

Wisdom for your commute: Download audio talks by Shane Claiborne, Brian McLaren, Lucy Winkett, and more. Shop the SojoStore.

Scared of being ‘left behind’? What does Revelation really teach us? Explore this question with Sojourners’ four-part study guide, Christians and the Apocalypse. Use it this Sunday with your small group - available online. Click here.

An Award-Winning Magazine: Sojourners was recently named best general interest magazine by both the Associated Church Press and the Evangelical Press Association. Subscribe today!

T-Shirts That Teach. Start a conversation everywhere you go with Sojourners' tees on faith and social justice. Click here for more information. Starting at $10.






Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: sojourners@sojo.net | Advertising: advertising@sojo.net | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.