The Common Good

Afghanistan: A Whole New Approach

Sojomail - October 29, 2009


I have lost understanding of and confidence in the strategic purposes of the United States' presence in Afghanistan ... I have doubts and reservations about our current strategy and planned future strategy, but my resignation is based not upon how we are pursuing this war, but why and to what end.

- Matthew Hoh, a former Marine captain with combat experience in Iraq, in a letter resigning his State Department Foreign Service post in Afghanistan. Afghans, he wrote, are fighting the United States largely because its troops are an unwelcome occupier backing a corrupt national government. (Source: The Washington Post)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" -- our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

Afghanistan: A Whole New Approach

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners
Become a Facebook Fan of Sojourners
Become a Facebook fan
of Sojourners

Follow Sojourners on Twitter
Follow Sojourners
on Twitter

We’ve all been watching carefully as the Obama administration tries to decide how to move forward on U.S. policy in Afghanistan. And we’ve been listening to the arguments and counter-arguments being offered. Religious leaders in particular have been paying close attention to both the political and moral arguments that fill the air.

Contrary to Dick Cheney’s accusation that the administration is “dithering,” many of us feel that a period of discernment is clearly called for in Afghanistan. We know what Cheney wants America to do -- he never dithered, even when there were no facts to support his case for more war. Dick Cheney always wants to fight. But Cheney’s foreign policy was an embarrassment for America, and a tragedy for the rest of the world. And not to follow his advice is always a good first step of moral wisdom.

But we need more than that. What we need is a whole new approach in Afghanistan. The argument in Washington, D.C. is far too narrow. Two points of view are contending inside the Obama team, and on Capitol Hill. One supports a robust strategy of counter-insurgency, requiring a substantial escalation of troops that would bring the total number of U.S. forces to as many as 100,000. The other prefers counter-terrorism, relying on the most sophisticated technology and Special Forces precision to focus on the most dangerous operatives who are the greatest threat to us.

Of course these are all old arguments. Counter-insurgency increases the massive American footprint in Afghanistan, which is clearly one of the primary causes of our failures in that country thus far. Add in a corrupt Afghan government, a radically decentralized society, and a physical terrain that has confounded every other occupier in history there; it doesn’t make many of us hopeful, and painfully reminds us of a history that deeply formed us. The laser-like precision of our counter-terrorist missiles and unmanned drones may cost less in American lives and treasure, but they often don’t just hit the bad guys. They have resulted in serious civilian casualties, even further alienating the populace and producing more angry young recruits for terrorism. And the solution that may be emerging in Washington could be a confused combination of the two strategies, bringing us the worst of both worlds.

We need a whole different approach.

We should know by now, and most of those on the ground in places like Afghanistan do, that what re-builds a broken nation; inspires confidence, trust, and hope among its people; and most effectively undermines terrorism is an old and proven idea -- massive humanitarian assistance and sustainable economic development. And it costs less -- far less -- than continued war. Perhaps this was best put by Richard Stearns, the U.S. president of World Vision, at a recent meeting of President Obama’s Council on Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships in Washington, D.C., when he said, “The best face of America for the world is a baseball hat and not a helmet.”

Many of us have advised the president that the people who know places like Afghanistan the best are neither the military nor the private contractors who increasingly dominate U.S. foreign policy in war-torn regions. Rather they are the NGOs doing relief and development work who have been there for years, have become quite indigenous, and are much more trusted by the people of the country than are the U.S. military or their mercenary friends.

So here is the new approach. Lead with what works -- development. Yes, effective development needs security, and when you massively intervene in a country as much as the U.S. has in Afghanistan, you can’t responsibly just walk away -- as has tragically happened to this country too many times before. But we should lead with development now, and only provide the security necessary to protect the strategic rebuilding of the country that is urgently needed -- and that kind of security might better attract the international involvement we so desperately need in Afghanistan, even from Arab and Muslim countries.

And here is an idea of how to do that. Bring to the White House the international organizations who know Afghanistan well because they have been there so long -- such as World Vision, Mercy Corps, Catholic Relief Services, Oxfam, Tearfund, Christian Aid, Church World Service -- and many others. Ask them what U.S. policy would best work, and what kind of security they would need to really do the kind of development in Afghanistan that is most needed.

Let the non-military strategies lead the way, rather than the other way around, which often just makes aid and development work another weapon of war; but then provide the security needed for that work, and make it as international as possible. Also bring in some of the religious and other nonprofit leaders from the Obama Advisory Council and others, to focus on the deeply ethical and moral issues that are at stake in our decisions about future policy in Afghanistan -- legitimately protecting Americans from further terrorism, defending women from the Taliban, developing a diplomatic surge, genuinely supporting democracy, and saving innocent lives from the collateral damage of war -- to name a few.

The conversation is much too narrow right now on Pennsylvania Avenue and at the U. S. Congress. It’s time for a deeper look and a whole new approach. Stupid people might call that dithering; smart people would call it discernment.

E-mail E-mail this article to friends
Facebook Share this article on Facebook
Comment Comment on this article on the God's Politics Blog


George Schulz and Graphic Novels

Video Interview with George Schulz: In this video interview, former Secretary of State George Shulz talks about why he cares about ending nuclear proliferation, and how he believes we can enter into a world free of nuclear weapons.


graphic-novelsGraphic Novels Slideshow: For those in the comics industry, it has been a long push toward earning respectability among mainstream readers. That effort has consisted largely of convincing readers that while many comic books are silly and fun, the medium offers plenty of substantive material as well. See a slideshow of some of the most substantial graphic novels of our time.


Dealing with the Problem at the Root

A year ago, a crisis -- brought on by a financial industry hooked on greed, short-term profits, and heedless risk-taking -- nearly brought the world economy to a grinding halt. Congress is working to address the problems that led to the current economic crisis, but the banking industry is pouring millions into lobbying efforts to oppose and weaken reform legislation.

As Christians, we can advocate for a just financial system based on the wisdom of scripture. The Bible commends “those who deal generously and lend, who conduct their affairs with justice” (Psalm 112:5), and condemns those who oppress the poor and needy for their own gain (Ezekiel 18:10-13).

Currently, there is a Congressional proposal to establish a Consumer Financial Protection Agency -- an independent agency charged with enforcing consumer protection rules, reigning in abusive financial practices, and closing loopholes in the existing system.

Join us in telling Congress to act now in restoring integrity to our financial system and ensuring that the current economic crisis is not repeated.


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

From Bethlehem: A Human Story
by Lynne Hybels

When it comes to Israel/Palestine, the human story often gets lost in the confusion of ideology and politics. Let me just highlight the story of one woman, a wife and mother named Isme.
+ Click to continue

The Health-Care Roller Coaster Rolls On
by Valerie Elverton Dixon

We continue the roller coaster ride that we hope will end with universal or near universal coverage for health care in the United States. Those of us who favor, at the very least, a public option had reason to be glad on one day and reason to be sad the next.
+ Click to continue

Exorcising the Demons of a Church's Racial Divide
by Edward Gilbreath

On a sad but pivotal day in the late 1780s, several of the African American members of Philadelphia's St. George's Methodist Church were thrown out of the church by the congregation's white leaders because of their refusal to sit in a blacks-only gallery area.
+ Click to continue

Half-Handed Cloud Audio Interview and Free Song Download
by Jeannie Choi

There are several factoids about John Ringhofer that elicit fandom, and none of them have anything to do with his music...
+ Click to continue

More Heat than Light: Randall Terry's 'Burn in Hell' Protest
by Chuck Gutenson

One wonders why we even take the time to respond. Yet one of the main obstacles to reasoned and civil discourse on health-care reform is the lack of challenge to such ridiculous claims as we see here.
+ Click to continue

Whip It: What a Girl Power Movie Should Be
by Julie Clawson

I discovered the most genuine and life-affirming coming of age story that I have seen in a long time. The story is that of small-town Texas girl, Bliss (Ellen Page), who escapes her mother's beauty pageant dreams for her life by entering a roller derby league.
+ Click to continue

Learning from the 'Lowly'
by Sheron Patterson

I am excited about the Justice Revival because it brings the lowly center stage, and we all can be blessed by them. Romans 12:15-16 tells us, "Rejoice with those who rejoice, weep with those who weep. Live in harmony with one another. Do not be haughty, but associate with the lowly." There are lessons from the lowly that Dallas needs to learn.
+ Click to continue

Redemptive Poetry on a Night of Violence
by Bart Campolo

It is Sunday night, and I am suddenly awake at the crack of too-close gunfire. I creep to the window without turning on the light, more curious than afraid until I remember I don't know if my daughter Miranda and her friends are home from their movie.
+ Click to continue

'Offensive Play': Why I've Watched My Last Superbowl
by Ernesto Tinajero

I found myself convicted when I read Malcom Gladwell's essay, "Offensive Play." Mr Gladwell tracks how football players suffer head injuries due to playing the sport. After reading the article, I felt the prompting of the Spirit to abandon any support for football. Now, mind you, I have been a fan of the game since boyhood. I have been a Washington Redskins fan for over thirty years.
+ Click to continue

A Prayer for the Earth
by Brian McLaren

Tim Costello of World Vision Australia and I have been working behind the scenes to compose a prayer that could be used by individuals and groups leading up to the Copenhagen gathering on climate change Dec. 6. Click here to read alternate versions of this prayer.
+ Click to continue

Confronting Urban Violence with Jesus' Nonviolence
by Efrem Smith

Peace and nonviolence cannot be seen as an outdated strategy of hippies and those who participated in the part of the civil rights movement directed by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Ministries to children, youth, and families must contain initiatives for conflict resolution rooted in the teachings of Jesus.
+ Click to continue

Signs of Evangelical Renewal
by Margaret Benefiel

Foremost among the critiques of what evangelicalism has become were, first, evangelicals' identification with the religious right and second, the narrow focus of evangelicals on church growth, to the exclusion of essential elements of the gospel.
+ Click to continue

Why I Choose to Be at Times, 'an Angry Asian Man'
by Eugene Cho

We often speak of 'loving our neighbors,' but it's really hard when we don't even know our neighbors. I see this to be a growing problem -- not just in the Church but our larger society. Why is it so hard to meet and grow with our neighbors?
+ Click to continue

The Evil Insurance Company Repents, But the Stuggle for Reform Continues
by LaVonne Neff

Never underestimate the power of a determined family, the press, the internet, and an outraged public. Guardian Life has changed its policy and apologized to the Pearl family. Ian Pearl will continue to receive the home care he needs.
+ Click to continue

We Need an Abrahamic Alliance of the 'Passionate Best'
by Rabbi Arthur Waskow

We know, "the worst are full of passionate intensity." But so can also be the best. We need an Abrahamic Alliance of the passionate best. The idolatry of worshiping force and violence, war and terrorism, takes root when there is too little energy devoted to the Infinite.
+ Click to continue

The Media's Favorite Catholic Culture Warrior
by John Gehring

It's sad, if unsurprising, that the media regularly turn to Donohue for a "Catholic view" on issues. While Donohue's bluster makes for sensational television, he rarely raises his voice to speak about issues at the heart of Catholic social teaching.
+ Click to continue

Cautious Optimism on Obama's New Sudan Policy
by Elizabeth Palmberg

If -- and only if -- it is fleshed out and put into vigorous action, the new policy could be the first step in course of putting concerted economic and other pressure on Khartoum.
+ Click to continue

Stories from Global Victims of Climate Change -- And an Interfaith Call to Action
by Juliet rabia Gentile

What if the soul of the world had an alarm clock and it began ringing ? would we wake up and listen? As we sat in the chapel that morning and "bore witness" to the harrowing stories of the victims of climate change, this question repeated itself over and over in my mind like a mantra.
+ Click to continue

Video: While Others Debate, They Wait
by Jim Wallis

Check out this evocative new ad produced by the American Values Network. It makes an important statement about our priorities in the health-care debate. I encourage you to share it with your friends.
+ Click to continue


+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" e-mail -- the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Could NAE's Pro-Immigration Reform Stance Open Door to Bipartisanship?
The Christian Post
“You know the wind has shifted in Congress when moderate and conservative evangelical leaders testify before the U.S. Senate in support of an earned pathway to citizenship for undocumented immigrants,” wrote Wallis, who is not a member of the more theologically conservative NAE. The head of the anti-poverty ministry Sojourners went on to compliment the evangelical body for setting a model for all Christians to take “seriously the call of scripture and act prophetically” when it comes to moral issues.
+Click to continue

Safety net too vital to let it fail
The Capital Times (Madison)
Last week, one of the strongest religious voices for those living on the margins of our society was in town. Rev. Jim Wallis, the editor of Sojourners magazine, is a leader in interfaith efforts to fight poverty. Looking back at the financial upheavals of the last year, Wallis told one small group, "We have a terrific safety net for the richest in this country." The leaders of government considered the giant banks, automakers and insurance companies to be too big to fail.
+Click to continue

Remembering God's Children Healthcare Ad
The Christian Broadcasting Network
Sojourners and The American Values Network is out with a television ad supporting healthcare reform. +Click to continue

"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way -- whether favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.


Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Wisdom for your commute: Download audio talks by Shane Claiborne, Brian McLaren, Lucy Winkett and more. Shop the SojoStore.

Stickers! Magnets! Buttons! Show your stuff with pithy statements from Sojourners. Order yours today.

Preaching the Word is Sojourners’ web-based Bible study and sermon prep service. Let leading voices on faith and social justice inspire you: Walter Brueggemann, Jim Wallis, Richard Rohr, Julie Polter, Ched Myers, Nadia Bolz-Weber, Paula Gooder, and more.

Scared of being ‘left behind’? What does Revelation really teach us? Explore this question with Sojourners’ four-part study guide, Christians and the Apocalypse. Use it this Sunday with your small group -- available online. Click here.

Changed people change the world. Subscribe to Sojourners. Click here.

Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.