The Common Good

The Professor and the Police Officer: Trapped in the 'Script'

Sojomail - July 30, 2009


The president will drink Bud Light. As I understand it -- I have not heard this, I’ve read this, so I’ll just repeat what I’ve read, that Professor Gates said he liked Red Stripe, and I believe Sergeant Crowley mentioned to the president that he liked Blue Moon. So we’ll have the gamut covered tomorrow afternoon.

- Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, on today’s “beer summit” at the White House. (Source: White House press office)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

The Professor and the Police Officer: Trapped in the 'Script'

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners

I have been away for the last couple of weeks, first for a family wedding and reunion on a lake in northern Michigan, and then at the Chautauqua conference center in rural New York state. Neither place had great media access (always part of a good vacation) but I kept up the best I could. All of a sudden, I saw the familiar face of Henry Louis (“Skip”) Gates on all the cable news shows -- someone I know from my own teaching at Harvard, where Gates is a distinguished professor. Then I heard the story unfold and repeat about a million times, as sensational cable news stories always do, especially when they are about race.

When I returned to D.C. this weekend, the story was everywhere. Even the president had weighed in, then clarified his statements, then tried to play his role as national racial reconciler (with a beer at the White House with the principle protagonists scheduled for today).

I have a good friend who is a D.C. cab driver. He is always a good analyst of Washington politics, so we plunged into the discussion. “I have been in his shoes,” said the 60-year-old African-American D.C. native. He confirmed that many other African Americans had been swapping their own stories of being stopped on the street, pulled over in their cars, confronted in stores, or just followed around -- or worse -- by police. I remember listening to the African-American mother of a friend of mine growing up in Detroit, who told her children to hide from the police if they ever were lost, while my mother told us kids to look for a policeman if we were far away from home. That is the context of this story for every black American, especially of Gates’ generation. Gates being arrested on his front porch after a report of breaking into his own home seems both incredulous and, at the same time, not surprising to most black people in America.

And that is the script of this racial drama being played out about the professor and the police officer. What most strikes me about the story is how neither participant was able to get out of the script of the sad story of the relationship between black people and white police in America.

Of course, as the facts of the story have unfolded, it gets complicated. Most people agree that the woman who called the police when she saw two men who looked like they were breaking into a house -- as Gates and his cab driver were trying to get into his house through a broken front door after an overseas trip -- was being a reasonable citizen (though many, including me, still wonder if the call would have been made if the two men had been white in Gates’ white neighborhood). And most agree that Officer Crowley is not the typical racist white cop, but rather one with an exemplary record, and is even a police trainer on matters of racial sensitivity and profiling. Most agree that the combination of outrage, ego, and jet lag likely provoked the wrath of Skip Gates on a white cop answering a suspected burglary call and treating him like a suspect at his own home. From what we can piece together from the conflicting accounts of the angry words that ensued between them, it is clear to me that both got caught up in the script, and neither was able to extricate himself from it.

Gates’ reported behavior felt offensive and abusive to the police officer, but an immediate acceptance of Gates’ identity and residence, followed by a quick and effusive apology by Crowley, might have calmed the storm. And in any event, disrespectful behavior to a police officer is not against the law, and an arrest for disorderly conduct of a small 58-year-old man with a cane, on his own porch, when there was no threat to public safety, does appear to justify the accuracy, if not the political wisdom, of President Obama’s suggestion that handcuffing Gates was acting “stupidly.”

Police officers should get a great deal of sympathy, understanding, and support for often very tough split-second decisions where the lives of citizens, or their own lives, are at stake, but this was clearly not one of those situations. And Washington Post columnist Eugene Robinson insightfully treated the charge of Gates’ alleged “You have no idea who you’re messing with” elitism when he observed that “meeting a famous Harvard professor who happens to be arrogant is like meeting a famous basketball player who happens to be tall.”

The real issue here is two men who didn’t believe the other showed him proper deference. Thus, again we have fundamental issues of power at stake -- this time between an upper-class black Harvard professor and a working-class white Boston cop. And guess what? The script took over. The Reconciler-in-Chief will likely get them both to behave better at the White House and get, if not apologies, at least a chilling out for the good of the nation. But if this incident is to become a teachable moment, there are at least two lessons to be learned.

The first is that racial profiling, whether or not it was involved in this particular case, is still real and indeed brutal in key sectors of our society -- in particular, the criminal justice system. Clear and pervasive racial discrimination still exists in law enforcement, judicial practices, and penal policies at the bottom of American life even if things are much more complicated and nuanced at the top in places like Cambridge. One of the best articles about this controversy, which draws attention to the real and structural racial injustice still present in American society, is Glen Loury’s op-ed in Sunday’s New York Times:

“Certainly, the contretemps shed no relevant light on the plight of the millions of black men on society’s margins who bear the brunt of police scrutiny and government-sanctioned coercion,” writes Loury. “Nevertheless, this is a principal source of the tension in interactions between the police and black men like me.”

But the second lesson is about the script itself and how to get out of it. The best way to defuse, diminish, and ultimately dismantle its power is to show even excessive respect in potential situations of conflict. Let’s call it “affirmative respect” as a parallel to affirmative action. Nothing defuses a potential conflict like proactively showing such respect in just these kinds of situations, and Crowley should be teaching that in his racial diversity classes. Of course, respect should go both ways, but it must be said that the burden of respect will and should be on white people. Sorry folks, but that is just the burden of our racial history. And you don’t have to be guilty of that history in order to be responsible for it. Most white people in America have benefited from racial discrimination even if they are not personally guilty of it, and are therefore obliged to now show that extra measure of respect. A new generation of black and white people with less baggage and less of a chip on their shoulders will certainly help us all. But doing our part to diminish the power of the script is all of our responsibility. Two men in Cambridge didn’t do a good job of that last week, which could teach us all to do a little better.

+ Click to share this article

+ Click to respond to this article on the God's Politics Blog


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

My Summer Road Trips
by Jim Wallis

For our family, summer is road trip time. Long road trips are a great opportunity to talk, tell stories, laugh, read, knit, and watch movies.
+ Click to continue

Gates Arrest Analysis Cliff Notes
by Ryan Rodrick Beiler

Officer Crowley and Professor Gates are scheduled for a beer with President Obama today. Let's hope their conversation is a model for reconciliation -- and not a reflection of the media hype that has provided much heat and little light.
+ Click to continue

Demanding Justice for the People who Harvest our Food
by Melanie Weldon-Soiset

I watched the documentary Food, Inc. and it left me inspired in a surprising way -- for workers' rights. In a system that values efficiency above all else, food companies often regard their employees similarly to their animals.
+ Click to continue

Health-Care Reform: Leading with Respect
by Melvin Bray

Americans are dying for want of health care. Since the 1912 electoral defeat of Republican stalwart Theodore Roosevelt -- supporter of universal coverage -- we the people have been nationally conscious of this grim fact, yet still find it debatable.
+ Click to continue

'Grace to Heal': Deconstructing the Culture of Violence in Zimbabwe
by Nontando Hadebe

The government of Zimbabwe, in a groundbreaking move, dedicated this past weekend to renouncing political violence and promoting national healing. Given past denials of violence, this move has opened up a space for confronting the reality of violence in post-independent Zimbabwe.
+ Click to continue

Health-Care Reform is a Life and Death Issue
by Mary Nelson

We need health-care reform to ensure that others aren't caught in the web of inconsistent mental health care and the inability to get needed medicine. Here is the experience of my brother and sister-in law (Rev. Jon and Juni Nelson) in the death of their son Joshua ...
+ Click to continue

An Evangelical Who Doesn't Like Sarah Palin
by Jim Wallis

I heard CNN senior political correspondent Candy Crowley say "evangelicals" just love Sarah Palin .... I am tired of the stereotype. There are a lot of evangelicals, like me (and especially younger evangelicals), who are just embarrassed by Sarah Palin.
+ Click to continue

Fear, Race, and Pride in the Gates Arrest
by Alan Bean

A New York Times piece picks up on a question Scott Henson introduced on his blog: What does the behavior of Sgt. Crowley of the Cambridge PD say about police culture? Not surprisingly, there is little consensus among police officers on the thick-skin vs. zero tolerance question.
+ Click to continue

Talking While Stupid
by Brian McLaren

I think President Obama was right to soften the tone of his statement the other day on the Gates arrest incident; "stupid" wasn't a helpful word choice. But the word, I think, accurately describes the reaction of a lot of white male commentators to the incident.
+ Click to continue

The Dark Side of Development
by Chris Baker Evens

Development is a word full of hope. It brings to mind water pumps and rice banks, bridges and education, smiling children and sky-scraping financial institutions. Yet there is a dark side to development.
+ Click to continue

Mark Sanford, John Ensign, and 'The Family'
by Becky Garrison

Presently, the glare of the media spotlight has started to shine on a number of political figures, all of whom coincidentally have a connection to a D.C.-based group called The Family.
+ Click to continue

Celebrating the Minimum Wage Increase
by Melanie Weldon-Soiset

People of faith can celebrate today as the federal minimum wage increases from $6.55 to $7.25 an hour. After wages stagnated for a decade at a 1997 hourly rate of $5.15, today's boost is the third and final one in an annual series that Congress approved in 2007.
+ Click to continue

Health Care and Structural Violence
by Valerie Elverton Dixon
America commits structural violence against more than 40 million of her citizens who do not have health insurance.
+ Click to continue

How to Win a Culture War
by Jim Wallis

Want to know how to win a culture war? Don't fight one. The soul of our nation has been marred from a perpetual state of culture war.
+ Click to continue

Debating Race
by Edward Gilbreath

Are we living in the golden age of racial debates? Every week seems to bring some new wrinkle in the national conversation about race, class, and ethnicity. And with the emergence of social media, we can now engage in these conversations with ever-greater frequency and intensity.
+ Click to continue

Mr. Obama, Our Immigration Enforcement Policy Perpetuates Racial Profiling
by Allison Johnson

I was surprised when Obama expanded his remarks on racial profiling to include Latinos, because profiling is perpetuated under an enforcement program of his own administration, known as 287g. This federal program under the Department of Homeland Security deputizes local police to enforce immigration law.
+ Click to continue

Four Lessons from the Religious Right
by Brian McLaren

This Seattle Times article on the current state of the Religious Right union matches my own sense of things in my travels across the country. I've heard conservative evangelicals say almost word for word what people quoted in this article say ... The times are changing.
+ Click to continue


+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" e-mail - the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Would God back universal health care?
USA Today
The Rev. Jim Wallis, a Christian activist and founder of Sojourners magazine, has warned that there is one additional role clergy will be playing in the upcoming debate: helping us get at the truth. "Lying is not allowed here," he says. No doubt Wallis remembers the rancorous 1993-94 health care debate with its infamous Harry and Louise ads. +Click to continue

Abortion Reduction Bill Draws Religious Friends & Foes
The Washington Post blog
On the opposite end of the spectrum, Jim Wallis, a prominent leader among progressive evangelicals, has come out strongly supporting the bill. The legislation, he said, "addresses both how best to prevent unwanted pregnancies and support pregnant women who desire to carry their baby to term. It also makes adoption easier. The bill demonstrates how searching for common ground can lead to higher ground, in ways that both sides of the debate can embrace." +Click to continue

Religious Divide Continues on Health Care Reform and Abortion Issues
The Washington Post blog

Pulling Together On Health Care
The Washington Post

New push in Congress for common ground on abortion
The Associated Press

Democratic Bill Could Be a Preview of Obama's Abortion Plan
U.S. News and World Report blog

Calls mount for ‘clear’ prohibition of abortion funding in health-care legislation
Catholic News Agency

Progressive Christian Leader Backs 'Common Ground' Abortion Prevention Bill
The Christian Post

Why The New Abortion Common Ground Bill Matters (Ryan-DeLauro)

"Don't Be Mad at Me for Wanting to Solve the Problem"
The Huffington Post

The Early Word: More Town Hall Sessions on Health Care
The New York Times blog

Bring on government health plan
Lexington Herald-Leader

"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way - favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.


Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Earn your Masters from top-ranked Abilene Christian University Online. Abilene offers graduate degrees in Education, Conflict Resolution, and Organizational & HR Development. Ranked within the top 25 of America's Best Colleges and as the #1 Innovator by U.S. News

NEW CD - CompassionArt: Martin Smith (Delirious?), Israel Houghton, Michael W. Smith, and many more collaborated on CompassionArt, a 14-song CD/DVD exploring music that inspires and challenges. Read the liner notes.

Summer reading: Books by New York Times best-selling author Jim Wallis: The Great Awakening, God’s Politics, The Call to Conversion, Faith Works, and the Soul of Politics. Visit the SojoStore.

Faith and Finances: Christians and the Economic Crisis. Sojourners’ new discussion guide gives a faithful perspective on money, power, and stewardship. Great for Sunday school classes, small groups, sermon preparation. Download now.

God's Politics Blog facebook
MySpace YouTube

Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.