The Common Good

A Christian Mistake

Sojomail - April 16, 2009


Few of us can trace our ancestry to the Mayflower. But it’s worth noting that, from a Native American perspective, those Massachusetts Bay pilgrims were illegals.

- Timothy Egan, in his New York Times blog post about new Commerce secretary -- and first Chinese-American governor -- Gary Locke, whose grandfather lied to get into the U.S. (Source: The New York Times)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

A Christian Mistake

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners

In ominous red and black, last week’s Newsweek cover carried the headline, “The Decline and Fall of Christian America.” The magazine’s cover story by editor Jon Meacham provoked a wide array of reactions from across the spectrum. Whether Meacham is ultimately correct in his observance of these trends and his interpretation of their meaning is yet to be seen. The 1966 Time magazine cover that asked “Is God Dead?” could not have foreseen the development of religion in American public life over the past 40 years, and we shouldn’t expect any more from Newsweek. What the latter cover has accomplished is to raise questions vital to both the health of the Christian tradition and for the public discourse of our nation.

The question that struck me and the one I began to address in a short piece for Newsweek was that of the role of religion in public life and politics. Here’s what I had to say:

The Religious Right was a Christian mistake. It was a movement that sought to implement a “Christian agenda” by tying the faithful to one political option -- the right wing of the Republican Party. The politicizing of faith in such a partisan way is always a theological mistake. But the rapid decline of the Religious Right now offers us a new opportunity to re-think the role of faith in American public life.

Personally, I am not offended or alarmed by the notion of a post-Christian America. Christianity was originally and, in my view, always meant to be a minority faith with a counter-cultural stance, as opposed to the dominant cultural and political force. Notions of a “Christian America” quite frankly haven’t turned out very well.

But that doesn’t mean a lack of religious influence — on the contrary. Committed minorities have had a tremendous influence on cultures and even on politics. Just look at all the faith-inspired social-reform movements animated by people of faith. But Martin Luther King Jr. did not get the Civil Rights Act passed because he had the most Bible verses on his side but because he entered into the public square with compelling arguments, vision, and policy that ultimately won the day. Those faith-inspired movements are disciplined by democracy, meaning they don’t expect to win just because they are “Christian.” They have to win the debates about what is best for the common good by convincing their fellow citizens.

And that is best done by shaping the values narrative, as opposed to converting everyone to their particular brand of religion. Rather, they are always looking for allies around their moral causes, including people of other faiths or of no religion. The story of Christianity in America in the coming decades will be defined by a multicultural shift as well as a generational one. “New” evangelicals and Catholics, along with black, Hispanic, and Asian churches will now shape the agenda. But also included are the millions of Americans who say they are “spiritual but not religious,” finding homes in non-traditional churches, mega-churches that teach that true religion is found in care for “the least of these.” Making a real impact on the values and directions that a democracy will choose is, perhaps, a more exciting kind of influence than relying on the illusory and often disappointing hopes of cultural and political dominance.

Barack Obama stirred the pot around this exact question recently with his comment at a press conference in Turkey that “we do not consider ourselves a Christian nation.” This statement is not a new one for Obama. He expressed it clearly during a 2006 speech to a Sojourners/Call to Renewal conference. He explained his position this way:

Democracy demands that the religiously motivated translate their concerns into universal, rather than religion-specific, values. It requires that their proposals be subject to argument, and amenable to reason. I may be opposed to abortion for religious reasons, but if I seek to pass a law banning the practice, I cannot simply point to the teachings of my church or evoke God’s will. I have to explain why abortion violates some principle that is accessible to people of all faiths, including those with no faith at all.

Now this is going to be difficult for some who believe in the inerrancy of the Bible, as many evangelicals do. But in a pluralistic democracy, we have no choice. Politics depends on our ability to persuade each other of common aims based on a common reality. It involves the compromise, the art of what’s possible. At some fundamental level, religion does not allow for compromise. It’s the art of the impossible. If God has spoken, then followers are expected to live up to God’s edicts, regardless of the consequences. To base one’s life on such uncompromising commitments may be sublime, but to base our policy making on such commitments would be a dangerous thing.

The shift that Jon Meacham describes may be the best news in a long time.

+ Click to share to this article

+ Click to respond to this article on the God's Politics Blog


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

Four Points Toward Peace in the Middle East
by Brian McLaren

Any of us who travel (or read) know that peace in the world can't be separated from peace in Israel -- peace for Jews, and peace for Muslim and Christian Palestinians.
+ Click to continue

Video: The Easter Bunny Asks You to Rethink Afghanistan
by Anna Almendrala

If you were in Washington, D.C., for the Easter holiday, you may have noticed a different kind of Easter Bunny hanging around. Instead of handing out jellybeans and chocolate, this bunny was handing out plastic eggs filled with a little toy soldier and a question about the war in Afghanistan.
+ Click to continue

The Power to Dominate and the Power to Love
by César Baldelomar

As Christians, our continual task is to explore and meditate on Jesus' teachings, as well as to emulate his deeds. Central to this two-fold task is comprehending the type of power Jesus wielded -- namely, the power to love.
+ Click to continue

American Violet: Drug War Injustice Hits the Big Screen
by Alan Bean

American Violet tells the story of Regina Kelly, one of the people rounded up in a Tulia-style drug bust in Hearne, Texas, almost 10 years ago. The Hearne tragedy would never have come to light without Tulia.
+ Click to continue

A Good Story: 'I'm Going to Kill You'
by Bart Campolo

I often tell people not to ask me for statistics because in this work all the statistics are bad. Ask me for stories instead, I say, because even in the worst of times I always have a good story.
+ Click to continue

Video: 'Beyond Belief' - An Interview with David Wilcox
by Robin Fillmore

David Wilcox sat down with me to share thoughts about his latest CD, Open Hand. In the interview and on the CD, David provides his gratifyingly consistent mixture of melody and message that invites followers to explore with him the "outrageous carpenter."
+ Click to continue

Might Will Never Make Right In Afghanistan
by Randy Woodley

I consider myself a peacemaker and a patriot. I come from a long line of warriors and military servicemen. But, along with other Americans in my generation, the idea of blind patriotism died for me during the Vietnam War. Then, after my conversion in 1975, I found Jesus had much more to say about making peace than making war.
+ Click to continue

Sacred Jazz: An Interview with Deanna Witkowski
by Edward Gilbreath

For many of us, jazz music is reserved for smoky nightclubs or public-radio broadcasts. That's why pianist/singer Deanna Witkowski is something of an anomaly. She's a musician who feels as much at home in a secular club as an evangelical sanctuary.
+ Click to continue

Taxes and Tithes, Contract and Covenant
by Valerie Elverton Dixon

We pay taxes because of the social contract and the law. We pay tithes because of the covenant with Almighty God, love of God, self, and neighbor, and because of the blessed assurance that the promises of God are true.
+ Click to continue

Eric Holder, Ted Stevens, and Prosecutorial Misconduct that Doesn't Make Headlines
by Alan Bean

No one is saying that Ted Stevens didn't lie about unreported contributions. But the government has to play by the rules even when the defendant is guilty.
+ Click to continue

The Eco-Footprint of War: Lemeyo's Story
by Amanda Hendler-Voss

Lemeyo Abon, an indigenous elder from the Marshall Islands, is a survivor of fallout from the largest nuclear bomb ever detonated by the U.S. Last month, she told her story to people of faith at Ecumenical Advocacy Days, then shared it with members of Congress on Capitol Hill.
+ Click to continue

50 Ways to Love Your Neighbor
by Shane Claiborne

Here are 50 ways -- some little, some bigger -- that we can start to be the church we pray for.
+ Click to continue

Colorblinded in the Workplace
by Edward Gilbreath

"Is colorblindness or multiculturalism better for minorities?" Dawn Turner Trice talks about a recent University of Georgia study on "colorblindness" in the workplace. The study's findings suggest that pursuing a colorblind culture may not be the best approach in a work environment -- or in life.
+ Click to continue

Making a Difference in Darfur
by Jim Wallis

An op-ed piece in Monday's Wall Street Journal, on which I collaborated with John Prendergast, co-founder of the Enough Project.
+ Click to continue

Prophetic Voices on Taxes
by Chuck Collins

How many poor and disabled people will suffer before we can have a moral discussion about taxation? For three decades, we've shifted tax responsibilities off the wealthy and onto wage earners.
+ Click to continue

Call me Eugene MacGyver
by Eugene Cho

What do you do with something like this? "North Texas legislator during House testimony on voter identification legislation said Asian-descent voters should adopt names that are 'easier for Americans to deal with.'"
+ Click to continue

Alive and One in Christ
by Mimi Haddad

Through Christ's victory over death, we not only receive forgiveness for sin -- but if that were not enough, integral to the good news of the cross we also receive peace with God and also with one another.
+ Click to continue

Witchhunt: I Was in Prison and You Visited Me
by Cathleen Falsani

The Kniffens were only two of more than three dozen defendants who were accused of subjecting children to horrors in elaborate molestation and satanic ritual abuse rings in the 1980s. The accusations were shocking. Outrageous. Unbelievable. And, the years would reveal, wholly untrue.
+ Click to continue


+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" e-mail - the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Head of Obama's Faith-Based Office to Join Pastors for Anti-Poverty Symposium
The Christian Post
"We need more active faith coalitions breaking down the barriers to justice and inspiring hope in our urban neighborhoods," says the Rev. Jim Wallis, CEO and founder of Sojourners, the sponsor of the Mobilization to End Poverty event.

+Click to continue

GOD IN GOVERNMENT: The Best From This Week's Blog
The Washington Post blog

Obama heads to church for Easter Sunday
The Associated Press

Christians Urge Obama to Keep Conscience Clause
Christianity Today blog

Some Christians Applaud Obama's Push for Immigration Reform
The Christian Post

Church emissary takes a stand against poverty
The Courier-Post

Jepson alumni model leadership and community service nationally.
Richmond - The Alumni Magazine

Seeking to unite theology and politics
Otago Daily Times

"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way - whether favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.


Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Make a difference for Israeli-Palestinian peace! Register online today for the Churches for Middle East Peace 2009 Advocacy Conference. Join us June 7-9, for inspiring speakers, issue workshops, and visits with lawmakers on Capitol Hill!

Register for the early bird price of $25 until April 20 at and hear Joshua DuBois, Jim Wallis, Barbara Williams-Skinner and local leaders discuss solutions for poverty in D.C.!

Your sermons should spark discussion after service. With Preaching the Word sermon prep, you get lectionary reflections, context, themes, and current events compiled by the editors of Sojourners to help your sermon start conversations. Learn more.

Scared to talk politics in church? Get the conversation going in your small group with Sojourners discussion guides. Lots of topics and great talking points on challenging aspects of social justice. Learn more.

Are you Hungry for Justice? Start the discussion and take it to a deeper level in your church with Sojourners’ best-selling resource, Hungry for Justice. This six-week guide explores the Bible’s call to social justice and service to the poor.

Terrorism aims to inspire fear, and terrorist recruiting thrives on a cycle of violence. How can and should people of faith respond? Explore this issue with Sojourners’ four-part study, A Moral Response to Terrorism. Learn more.

God's Politics Blog facebook
MySpace YouTube

Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.