The Common Good

Counting the Cost

Sojomail - March 26, 2009


In the criminal justice system, anyone arrested is assumed innocent, but in the immigration system, they're put in detention, and then it's the individual's burden to prove they shouldn't be detained ... [I]t's an incredibly high burden.

- Sarnata Reynolds, an author of the recently released report from Amnesty International: "Jailed Without Justice: Immigration Detention in the USA" (Source: San Francisco Chronicle)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

Counting the Cost

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners
While watching President Obama’s press conference Tuesday evening, I was struck by a few things that are often forgotten in the criticism of his proposed budget.

Count the Cost

It is commonly accepted by biblical scholars that upon being warned about a plot by Herod Antipas to kill him, Jesus called Herod “that fox” (Luke 13:32). Biblical scholars such as John Ortberg also believe that Jesus was referring to Herod in Luke 14:28-32, with references to an embarrassing military overreach in which Herod failed to count the cost before going to war.

Suppose one of you wants to build a tower. Will he not first sit down and estimate the cost to see if he has enough money to complete it? For if he lays the foundation and is not able to finish it, everyone who sees it will ridicule him, saying, “This fellow began to build and was not able to finish.” Or what king, going out to wage war against another king, will not sit down first and consider whether he is able with ten thousand to oppose the one who comes against him with twenty thousand? If he cannot, then, while the other is still far away, he sends a delegation and asks for the terms of peace.

Jesus didn’t hesitate to publicly call out a king who failed to count the cost of a war, even when that king was out to kill him. Throughout the Bush presidency, we saw exactly this failure to count the cost of war. When President Clinton left office, our nation was benefiting from a $127 billion budget surplus. With the books now closed on the Bush years, the Obama administration has inherited a $1.3 trillion deficit. This deficit was accrued by a reckless pursuit of conservative ideology with tax cuts for the rich, while hiding the true cost of a war by deliberately leaving war spending out of the budget, and financing the venture through emergency supplemental bills. Government spending skyrocketed, while responsibility for paying off the debt passed on to our children.

And paying for war does not end when the conflict is over. Whether or not we agreed with the war doesn’t relieve us of our moral obligation to take care of those who fought it. Service providers have been reporting a new generation of homeless veterans living on our streets for several years now, and their physical and mental injuries will leave some vets unable to assume full employment for the rest of their lives.

Good Debt and Bad Debt

This is a difference that we all have had to work through. It is the difference between going into debt for something that will bear greater returns in the long run, or going into debt for things that will only depreciate in value. Another way of saying it is knowing the difference between wants and needs. We encourage our children to go to college even though they will have to take on some debt to do so, because the benefits of a college education far outweigh the amount of debt accrued. (Although college costs have now increased so significantly that some students are now finding out that even college debt can be bad debt.) We don’t encourage our children to put $1,000 on a credit card, with an interest rate of 30%, to buy an entertainment system they don’t need. Why? Because the entertainment system brings a moment of pleasure but does not add any long-term value to the child’s life.

When we look at the president’s budget, we have to ask ourselves whether the deficits it will incur are good debt or bad debt. Are the things being paid for a want or a need? While Bobby Jindal publicly mocked spending on volcano monitoring, this week’s eruption in Alaska and past eruptions such as Mount St. Helens have shown that a small investment now can save far greater sums of money in the long run -- and even save lives.

The president has outlined three areas of spending in his new budget that will help by immediately stimulating demand within our economy and by adding long-term value to the country. The first is education, with the president deciding that it is worth going into debt to increase the quality of and opportunities for education in our country. The second, spending on health care, also adds long-term value to our society. Every year billions of dollars are spent unnecessarily when people put off treatment because they are worried they can’t afford it. Third, there are long-term benefits from spending on the environment and infrastructure. Spending on environmental improvements creates jobs that cannot be sent overseas, and will also reduce the high health-care costs associated with various environmental maladies. Debt, of course, must come back down to a sustainable level, but the way to get it there is by investing now in areas that will pay off in the next few years and for generations to come.

So yes, a lot of us are experiencing sticker shock with the new Obama budget. But this sticker shock is like the one of a student looking at their loans -- not a credit card bill racked up at Banana Republic. It is debt that requires discipline, hard work, and focus. But it is the good kind of debt, the kind of debt that can and will produce surpluses in the long run.

+ Click to share to this article

+ Click to respond to this article on the God's Politics Blog


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

Diagnosing Our Economic Illness
by Brian McLaren

Some might say that this is the worst possible time to have a Mobilization to End Poverty. A lot of people look at their retirement accounts and investment portfolios and feel that they're experiencing downward mobility -- so it's not a great time for them to help others experience upward mobility. But many of us realize the fact that we have retirement accounts and investments means that we are among the most fortunate, and that, having been given much, much is expected from us. And equally important, we understand our current economic crises to be a set of symptoms. Our symptoms are obvious, but the as-yet largely unanswered question is: What's the underlying disease that is creating our economic symptoms?
+ Click to continue

What Makes Liberals and Conservatives Angry? Abortion Reduction
by John Gehring

When both the Left and Right begin sharpening their knives, it means you are on to something. This new threat raising the hackles of liberals and conservatives still hunkered down in culture-war bunkers? It's a movement focused on comprehensive strategies to reduce abortions by providing economic supports for vulnerable women and preventing unintended pregnancies. A chorus of critics across the ideological spectrum has lined up to malign these common-ground efforts with all the righteous zeal of those who make the perfect the enemy of the good.
+ Click to continue

'Greek Moments' in South Africa and Zimbabwe
by Nontando Hadebe

During my studies in theology, my colleagues and I jokingly referred to particularly difficult concepts or issues that we had a hard time understanding as "a Greek moment," or say "this is Greek to me!" I had a "Greek moment" this week.
+ Click to continue

A Double Victory for Liberian Immigrants
by Bailey Craft

Last week, President Obama signed an executive order granting a 12-month extension to Liberians residing in the United States legally on a temporary immigration status.
+ Click to continue

Sin Nombre: Immigrants as Sojourners
by Craig Detweiler

President Obama recently addressed the crying need for comprehensive immigration reform. He reminded us that we are a nation of immigrants. Yet, for many, the question remains, "Why are so many people willing to risk so much to cross the U.S. border?" The award-winning independent film Sin Nombre elects to show, rather than tell us.
+ Click to continue

In Praise of Dimples
by Elizabeth Palmberg

There are just a few days left to share your thoughts about eating, body image, and faith in our society -- don't forget to send your two cents to! One thought I have (which didn't fit into Body Language, an article in this month's issue of Sojourners) is to realize how profoundly strange and useless the word "cellulite" is.
+ Click to continue

I'm the Older Brother
by Tony Campolo

When it comes to President Obama's stimulus package and its provisions to help those Americans who are having great difficulty paying their home mortgages, I have come to realize that I'm like the older brother in the story of the Prodigal Son.
+ Click to continue

Atheist Bus Ads Arrive in Seattle
by Eugene Cho

To support and amplify the already pervasive non-religious reputation of Seattle, the atheist bus ads are set to arrive .... I suspect that in the near future, some Christian group or folks here in Seattle will fund a set of new ads in response to these ads. And then at that point, I'd like to launch my own campaign and Web site ...
+ Click to continue

Romero: The Price of Preaching and Living Jesus' Gospel
by César Baldelomar

Twenty-nine years ago today, a Salvadorian government hit man assassinated Archbishop of San Salvador Oscar Romero as he was saying Mass in a convent. News of Romero's assassination sparked a slew of global responses -- from sadness and outrage to impartiality.
+ Click to continue

Three Priorities for Darfur
by John Prendergast

President Obama is overwhelmed by a multitude of crises, so he and the new Congress need to hear from us that Sudan is a priority too. President Obama appointed a Special Envoy this past week, which is a great first step. Now his administration needs to turn its attention to three policy priorities: feeding the hungry, demanding justice, and supporting peace.
+ Click to continue

Stop the Raids
by Jim Wallis

We are taking parents from their children; we are separating families. This is not what in our tradition we should do. Protecting and supporting families and those relationships is crucial. The immigration system is totally broken and needs comprehensive reform, but it must be changed in ways that are compassionate, fair, just, and consistent with the biblical command to "welcome the stranger."
+ Click to continue

My Definition of the Emerging Church
by Nadia Bolz-Weber

If I had a dollar for every person who has asked me "So, what IS the emerging church?" we could meet our budget this year. Here's my own definition, and it is just that -- my definition. Not the definition. This is descriptive, not prescriptive. When I use the term "emerging church" here's what I mean by that. (I feel like I'm walking into a minefield, but here we go ...)
+ Click to continue

Mocking Our Neighbor
by Julie Clawson

Last week Eugene Cho posted his thoughts on how it hurt him and his children when people, especially celebrities, do the slanty-eye thing mocking Asians. His post was simple -- basically, "hey people, that's offensive, stop doing it." One would kinda hope that we are way past the making-fun-of-other-people-because-of-their-race thing, but no such luck as the subsequent conversation displayed. Reading the comments there was a bit disturbing.
+ Click to continue

Rising Up to Heal a Sick Global System
by Andy Clasper

Jesus looked at the world around him and saw sickness in need of a doctor. He wanted God's people to wake up and realise that's what they were for. In the same way, some Christians today seem willing to confine their faith to religious practice, seeing no application for it in the realm of commerce, and avoiding politics as something unclean.
+ Click to continue

'Shooting and Crying': Israeli Soldiers Tell Their Gaza War Stories
by Ryan Rodrick Beiler

In last week's SojoMail, the quote of the week was from an Israeli squad leader describing the incredulous reactions of his men when he took measures to protect civilian lives during the invasion of Gaza. ... And this isn't just about Israel. This is about war -- especially wars fought by democracies who pride themselves on the superior morality of their methods and the "justice" of their cause.
+ Click to continue

Markets, Morality, and the Common Good
by John Gehring

Not long ago, those who demonized government and preached the gospel of free-market fundamentalism with evangelical zeal had few worries. The titans of corporate America were glorified on the cover of Fortune, "trickle-down" economics justified obscene wealth disparities, and a bullish Wall Street even gave working stiffs a piece of the action. But things fall apart. Decades of deregulation, crass decisions at the highest levels of business and government, and a consumer culture that celebrates materialism are catching up with reality.
+ Click to continue

You Can't Say That on TV, Mr. President
by Katie Van Loo

What shocked me out of my sleepy stupor much quicker than usual was the clip of Obama's interview on Leno last night. From President Obama's mouth: "I bowled a 129 .... It's like -- it was like the Special Olympics, or something." That is the presidential equivalent of saying, "That's retarded."
+ Click to continue

Staff Who Deserve Retention Bonuses
by Patricia Wudel

There's been quite a lot in the news recently about AIG and its concerns about retaining "talented staff" if bonuses go unpaid. I too work with exceptionally talented men and women.
+ Click to continue

Hard Facts of Immigrant Detention Centers
by Allison Johnson

The AP recently published a fascinating look at the hard facts about immigrant detention centers. My firsthand experience at a local maximum security jail, which doubles as an immigrant detention center, affirmed what I read in the article.
+ Click to continue


+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" e-mail - the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Obama Spiritual Counselor: Change Course on Afghanistan
The Nation blog
How much counsel the president is taking from the president and chief executive of Sojourners magazine and key player in a Washington-based activist network that takes the same name remains to be seen. But we can only hope that Obama is listening to Wallis on the question of how the United States should proceed in Afghanistan.
+Click to continue

Obama turns to religious leaders for advice
The Carolinian Online

PRESIDENT OBAMA DEVELOPS QUIET PRAYER GROUP: Barack and pastors hold prayer session and share views and perspective.

Obama Faith Council Member: Including Abortion Would Sink Health Care Reform

Church plans community garden
York Daily Record

"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way - whether favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.


Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Praying for Peace, Paying for War? Tax day is coming, while wars rage on. Check out the 2009 War Tax Boycott,, to find out how to redirect your tax dollars from war to peace.

Easter is another word for newness of life, a journey toward wholeness, and meaningful and compassionate relationships. I think of you as I reflect on the fullness of life promised by Jesus. Support the Maryknoll Sisters.

Hungry for Justice and Strangers in the Land - special price for two of Sojourners’ most popular study guides. Only through Sunday at midnight, get both for only $15 -- save $5 when you buy both now. Click here to save.

Poverty, Democracy, Nonviolence, Feminism, Racism, Slavery, Trade Justice. Sojourners’ discussion guides lead you through the tough issues with readings and questions to engage your individual study or small group. Learn more.

Let your laptop speak with the words of Micah 6:8 - "Act Justly, Love Mercy, Walk Humbly." Get your reusuable, long-lasting Sojourners’ laptop skin today. Click here to see and order today.

What Would Jesus Buy? Find out in this feature-length DVD from Morgan Spurlock of SuperSize Me. Rev. Billy and the Church of Stop Shopping discover the meaning of the Shopocalyse - the end of mankind from consumerism, over-consumption, and the fires of eternal debt. Click here for more information.

God's Politics Blog facebook
MySpace YouTube

Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.