The Common Good

The Big Debate

Sojomail - March 15, 2007


"She may not see eye to eye with Evangelicals on abortion and gay rights, but she will make the case (like many Democrats do) that biblical values run deeper to include poverty, the environment, the war in Iraq, stopping the genocide in Darfur, etc."

- more evidence for the broadening evangelical agenda from the congressional correspondent for Pat Robertson's Christian Broadcasting Network, David Brody, in positive comments about Hillary Clinton. (Source: CBN )

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail


The Big Debate

Last week, a letter from James Dobson and friends to the board of the National Association of Evangelicals challenged NAE vice president Rich Cizik's efforts on global warming as "dividing and demoralizing," claiming they shift "the emphasis away from the great moral issues of our time."

In response, I invited Dobson to a debate on the question, "What are the great moral issues of our time for evangelical Christians?" and suggested that a major evangelical Christian university should host it.

On Saturday, the Los Angeles Times reported on the debate invitation, and this response: "A Focus on the Family vice president, Tom Minnery, said he would be happy to take up that debate. Dobson himself, Minnery said, is busy writing a book on child rearing."

I’m also busy writing a book, but I suggest that when we’re both finished, we hold that debate. My personal invitation to James Dobson still stands. And since he was the primary driving force behind the crucial letter, the conversation should be with him. But let’s change the tone of this from "a debate" to "a conversation." This is, in fact, the big conversation going on among evangelicals (and Catholics, too) across the nation and around the world.

In his letter, Dobson named the "great moral issues" as "the sanctity of human life, the integrity of marriage and the teaching of sexual abstinence and morality to our children." I said in my last blog that I believe the sanctity of life, the integrity and health of marriages, and the teaching of sexual morality to our children are, indeed, among the "great moral issues of our time. But I believe they are not the only great moral issues." As many writers have been saying in this blog, the enormous challenges of global poverty, climate change, pandemics that wipe out generations and continents, the trafficking of human beings made in God’s image, and the grotesque violations of human rights, even to the point of genocide, are also among the great moral issues that people of faith must be - and already are - addressing.

Just in the last few days, we have already received invitations from six major Christian universities eager to host this conversation between James Dobson and me. But this is bigger than just two people: It’s the conversation we need to have on every Christian campus, in every church, and in public forums around the nation, especially as we approach another election season. So let’s do that together.

The board meeting of the National Association of Evangelicals also ended Saturday, and in the words of their own press release:
"NAE Leaders Advance Broad Agenda with Landmark Document on Human Rights and Torture." The release begins by noting:

The board of directors of the National Association of Evangelicals advanced a broad public agenda at its annual meeting this week, endorsing a landmark document on human rights and torture, and reaffirming its "For the Health of the Nation: An Evangelical Call to Public Engagement," first adopted in 2003.
Specifically, the board noted it

...reaffirmed its support for the landmark "For the Health of the Nation" document unanimously adopted in 2003, commending its "principles of Christian political engagement to our entire community for action."

These principles include: (1) We work to protect religious freedom and liberty of conscience; (2) We work to nurture family life and protect children; (3) We work to protect the sanctity of human life and to safeguard its nature; (4) We seek justice and compassion for the poor and vulnerable; (5) We work to protect human rights; (6) We seek peace and work to restrain violence; (7) We labor to protect God's creation.

The only mention of Rich Cizik, whom the Dobson letter had singled out and called upon the NAE to fire, came with these words in the official NAE press release:
Speaking at the annual board banquet, Rev. Richard Cizik, NAE vice president for governmental affairs, quoted evangelical theologian Carl F. H. Henry in his wake up call to evangelicals sixty years ago: ‘The cries of suffering humanity today are many. No evangelicalism which ignores the totality of man's condition dares respond in the name of Christianity.’
The NAE statement went on to say:
Speaking of a new generation of evangelicals that has responded to those cries, Cizik said: ‘We root our activism in the redemptive work of Jesus Christ on the cross and are giving it a proper temporal focus by emphasizing all of the principles that are found in the Bible. We come together in a positive way as a family bonded by the love of Christ, not as fractious relatives. We desire to be people known for our passionate commitment to justice and improving the world, and eager to reach across all barriers with love, civility, and care for our fellow human beings.’

I knew Carl F. H. Henry, during my seminary years at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School and through many conversations together during our early years of Sojourners. His biblical theology, social conscience, and political balance provided a younger generation with crucial moral guidance. We miss his voice today.

But the NAE board, and its president Leith Anderson, know that a new generation of evangelicals wants that same sound theology and good balance, and believe that Christian moral concerns (and God’s concerns) go beyond only a few issues. Recognizing how their broader agenda is resonating with evangelicals around the world, the NAE announced that at its fall board meeting in Washington, D.C., October 11-12, "the association will host an ‘International Congress on Evangelical Public Engagement,’ drawing prestigious leaders from around the world to meet with American leadership around the principles of the Association's ‘For the Health of the Nation’ document." It seems the broader evangelical social agenda has solid support and is moving forward.

So, let’s have the big debate, and make it into the kind of deep and necessary conversation among the people of God that it needs to be. And to Jim Dobson I say, let’s finish our books (as a Dad with two young boys I look forward to reading yours on child rearing!), and then agree to a public conversation at the right place and the right time. I look forward to that.

+ Read and respond to comments on this article on the God's Politics Blog


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

Jim Wallis: Evangelicals Against Torture
The struggle against torture and cruel treatment of prisoners by the U.S. received a major boost this week. In its recently concluded meeting, the National Association of Evangelicals board of directors last weekend endorsed an important new statement - An Evangelical Declaration of Torture: Human Rights in an Age of Terror.

Diana Butler Bass: Audio: The Practice of Diversity
Hear a recent sermon by Diana at Calvary Episcopal Church in Memphis, Tennessee.
+ Listen to the streaming audio

Geoff Thale: George’s Curious Adventures in South America
President Bush is finishing a trip to Latin America - a trip that the White House has billed as advancing "the cause of social justice in Latin America." From the rhetoric, you'd think that the president has finally recognized that poverty and inequality are the central issues in Latin America; that it is not free trade that we should be concerned about, nor Hugo Chavez, nor coca eradication, but rather the poverty that has persisted through more than a decade of "Washington Consensus" economic policies. These economic policies, promoted by successive U.S. administrations, and by the World Bank and other lending institutions, focused on expanding markets, reducing the role of the state in the economy, encouraging exports, and opening Latin American economies to U.S. imports. Unfortunately, these policies have had almost no impact on poverty or the unequal distribution of wealth.

Frida Berrigan: Gold Star for New Nukes?
At the beginning of March, the National Nuclear Security Administration announced the winner of the so-called "Reliable Replacement Warhead" competition that pitted the nuclear laboratories against each other. Lawrence Livermore won out against its long-time rival Los Alamos. If all goes according to plan, the Berkeley-based lab's design will eventually end up as submarine-launched intercontinental ballistic missiles. Still, NNSA administrator Thomas D'Agostino insisted that the new warhead "is not about starting a new nuclear arms race." But what else could it possibly be about? In the April 2007 issue of Sojourners I'll catch you up on the new nuclear surge.

Elise Elzinga: Hope from Despair in Cambodia's Sex Trade
The reality of Cambodia’s sex trafficking industry was vividly exposed to me one humid afternoon as I sat on a courtroom bench in Phnom Penh. I was sitting with four young girls as their sellers were escorted into the room. Their sellers were their mother, aunt, and grandmother. I didn’t need to understand the language to feel the fear, pain, and devastation that had just filled the room. I didn’t need to hear the words of the lawyer or the judge to understand the full situation.

Brian McLaren: Joseph, Noah, and Pre-emptive Preservation
As scientists go beyond identifying the threat of climate change to predicting its impact on global civilization, I wonder what it might look like for our nation and the nations of the world to take joint ameliorative action regarding greenhouse gases, and to take precautionary action regarding water and food. I wonder what it might be like for people of faith, like Joseph, to take a catalytic role in these efforts. And I wonder what mischief we might be legitimately distracted from if we came together around a cause like this. The biblical story of Noah comes to mind too, because so many species have already been pushed to the brink of extinction and beyond, and with rapid climate change, this tragic trend is likely to skyrocket. What would it be like for people of faith to follow Noah's example in preserving species wherever possible - by preserving natural habitat, and in other cases, creating "arks" to preserve species whose natural habitats are destroyed by flood or drought or melting ice or rising sea levels. People of God, both the Joseph and Noah stories suggest, are keenly interested in the common good - the good of all human beings and the good of all living creatures.

Elizabeth Palmberg: Sick of Corporate Trade
Who do you think should give nuts-and-bolts advice to help craft trade agreements that can cut Third World AIDS sufferers’ ability to buy lifesaving generic medicines? a) Pharmaceutical corporations, b) other large corporations, or c) public health advocates, including religious groups. Trick question! There are no public health advocates on the government-organized group that advises U.S. trade negotiators on medicines - just folks from Pfizer, Monsanto, and other corporate interests (plus one environmental group).

Scot McKnight: A Boring Box of Bones
I'll make a confession. I’ve lived long enough to see the emergence, the trend, and now the aging of the genre of Easter ambulance-chasing publishers. Every Lent, as Christians afflict themselves with minor fasting in order to participate more directly in the sufferings of Christ, and as Christians eagerly anticipate the good news called Easter, a publisher announces a new discovery, making the claim that the Christian gospel has neither a good Friday nor some good news. The genre is old, the trick has been seen before, and the American public knows the game.


Important Christian Peace Witness Update:

God's Spirit has moved thousands of people to come to Washington, D.C., to witness to their faith that Jesus calls us to be peacemakers. It appears that God intends for our witness to burst the seams of Washington with many more than can fit in the National Cathedral. God continues to call YOU and others to join this witness! However, seating in the National Cathedral is full.

+ Click here to sign up for:

1. Standing outside the Cathedral with 1,000 others to listen by loud speaker, and then joining the four-mile prayer procession to the White House, OR

2. Worshipping indoors with up to 1,000 other witnesses in the sanctuary of New York Ave Presbyterian Church, viewing and hearing the Cathedral service on large screen TV, and joining together in prayer and song. Following worship, this group will process by candlelight four blocks to Lafayette Park for the vigil there. This is an especially good option for those who cannot walk the four-mile procession from the Cathedral to the White House.

We need many, many thousands to surround the White House with the bright light of Christ and prayers for peace. Join us and bring your friends, so that in the spirit of Christ we might make a powerful witness to our government and the world.

+ To register for workshops, volunteering, nonviolent civil disobedience or other weekend events, click here.


"The Green Living Source for Today's Conscious Consumer"

Which products should you buy organic and why? Which fish are safe to eat? Can you keep your home clean without toxic chemicals? How can you be green in home furnishings and home improvements? The Green Guide answers these questions and so much more.

The Green Guide is the go-to source for green home tips, product reviews, environmental health and wellness information, and green living advice. Get well-researched, credible answers to your most important questions about everyday health and environmental issues for yourself and your family. Learn more about The Green Guide's special offer here.

Mennonite Central Committee seeks an Associate Executive Director. For a complete job description and more information, contact Kathy Jackson, Human Resources Director,, or at (717) 859-1151.

Discipleship Year: Volunteer program in Washington, DC. Take classes in faith and justice at Servant Leadership School, work in social justice ministry and live in community. Stipend and health insurance provided. Contact: Dawn Longenecker. Web: .

Employment Opportunity: Campus Minister for Interdenominational Ministry and Marianist Hall, University of Dayton, Dayton, Ohio. Job posting at Reference Job #P7019

Be a Tipping Point for Comprehensive Immigration Reform. Sojourners seeks a media-savvy organizer to coordinate the Christians for Comprehensive Immigration Reform campaign. Position is for a 9-month contract to start ASAP. Find out more here.

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.