The Common Good

Jim Wallis Criticizes James Dobson’s Distortion of Barack Obama’s Statements on Faith and Politics

Source: Sojourners
Date: June 24, 2008

June 24, 2008

Contact: Jason Gedeik, Sojourners, 202/230-2555, media@sojo.net

Jim Wallis Criticizes James Dobson’s Distortion of Barack Obama’s Statements on Faith and Politics

Evangelical leader Jim Wallis, author of The Great Awakening and founder of Sojourners, the largest network of progressive Christians in the United States, today criticized James Dobson, founder of Focus on the Family, for distorting Barack Obama’s statements on faith and politics at the annual Pentecost Conference in 2006 held by Sojourners.

Transcript of Barack Obama’s speech at Sojourners’ Pentecost 2006 conference:

http://obama.senate.gov/speech/060628-call_to_renewal/

Full Text of Jim Wallis’ Statement:

James Dobson, of Focus on the Family Action, and his senior vice president of government and public policy, Tom Minnery, used their "CitizenLink" radio show today to criticize Barack Obama’s understanding of Christian faith. In the show, they describe Obama as "deliberately distorting the Bible," "dragging biblical understanding through the gutter," "willfully trying to confuse people," and having a "fruitcake interpretation of the Constitution."

Now that James Dobson is insinuating himself into this presidential campaign, his attacks against his fellow Christian, Barack Obama, should be seriously scrutinized. And because his basis for the attack on Obama is the speech the Senator from Illinois gave at our Call to Renewal/Sojourners event in 2006 (for the record, we also had Democrat Hillary Clinton, and Republicans Rick Santorum and Sam Brownback speak that year), I have decided to respond to Dobson’s attacks. In most every case they are themselves clear distortions of what Obama said in that speech. I was there for the speech, Dobson was not.

You can read Obama’s now two-year old speech, which was widely publicized at the time and will see that Dobson either didn’t understand it or is deliberately distorting it. There are two major problems with Dobson’s attack today on Barack Obama.

First, Dobson and Minnery’s language is simply inappropriate for religious leaders to use in an already divisive political environment. We can agree or disagree on both biblical and political viewpoints, but our language should be respectful and civil, not attacking motives and beliefs.

Second, and perhaps most importantly, is the role of religion in politics. Dobson alleges that Obama is saying:

"I [Dobson] can’t seek to pass legislation, for example, that bans partial-birth abortion because there are people in the culture who don’t see that as a moral issue. And if I can’t get everyone to agree with me, it is undemocratic to try to pass legislation that I find offensive to the Scripture. … What he’s trying to say here is unless everybody agrees; we have no right to fight for what we believe."

Contrary to Dobson’s charge, Obama was very strong in defending the right and necessity of people of faith bringing their moral agenda to the public square, and was specifically critical of many on the left and in his own Democratic Party for being uncomfortable with religion in politics.

Obama said that religion is and has always been a fundamental and absolutely essential source of morality for the nation, but also said that "religion has no monopoly on morality," which is a point that I often make. The United States is not the Christian theocracy that people like James Dobson seem to think it should be. Political appeals, even if rooted in religious convictions, must be argued on moral grounds rather than as sectarian religious demands—so that the people (citizens), whether religious or not, may have the capacity to hear and respond. Religious convictions must be translated into moral arguments, which must win the political debate if they are to be implemented. Religious people don’t get to win just because they are religious. They, like any other citizens, have to convince their fellow citizens that what they propose is best for the common good— for all of us and not just for the religious.

Instead of saying that Christians must accept the "the lowest common denominator of morality," as Dobson accused Obama of suggesting, or that people of faith shouldn’t advocate for the things their convictions suggest, Obama was saying the exact opposite—that Christians should offer their best moral compass to the nation but then have to engage in the kind of democratic dialogue that religious pluralism demands. Martin Luther King Jr. perhaps did this best of all with his Bible in one hand and the Constitution in the other.

One more note. I personally disagree with how both the Democrats and Republicans have treated the moral issue of abortion and am hopeful that the movement among toward a serious commitment for dramatic abortion reduction will re-shape both Party’s language and positions. But that is the only "bloody notion" that Dobson mentions. What about the horrible bloody war in Iraq that Dobson apparently supports, or the 30,000 children who die each day globally of poverty and disease that Dobson seldom mentions, or the genocides in Darfur and other places? In making abortion the single life issue in politics and elections, leaders from the Religious Right like Dobson have violated the "consistent ethic of life" that we find, for example, in Catholic social teaching. Dobson has also fought unsuccessfully to keep the issue of the environment and climate change, which many also now regard as a "life issue," off the evangelical agenda. Older Religious Right leaders are now being passed by a new generation of young evangelicals who believe that poverty, "creation care" of the environment, human trafficking, human rights, pandemic diseases like HIV/AIDS, and the fundamental issues of war and peace are also "religious" and "moral" issues and now a part of a much wider and deeper agenda. That new evangelical agenda is a deep threat to James Dobson and the power wielded by the Religious Right for so long. Many evangelical votes are in play this election year, especially among a new generation, and are no longer captive to the Religious Right. Perhaps that is the real reason for James Dobson’s attack today on Barack Obama.

# #

Jim Wallis is a bestselling author, public theologian, speaker, preacher, and international commentator on religion and public life, faith and politics. His recent book, "The Great Awakening, Reviving Faith and Politics In a Post-Religious Right America," debuted at number 10 on the New York Times bestseller list. Jim’s previous book, "God's Politics: Why the Right Gets It Wrong and the Left Doesn't Get It" was on the list for 4 months. He is President and Chief Executive Officer of Sojourners; where he is editor-in-chief of Sojourners magazine, whose combined print and electronic media have a readership of more than 250,000 people.

Sojourners’ mission is to articulate the biblical call to social justice, inspiring hope and building a movement to transform individuals, communities, the church, and the world. Visit www.sojo.net, and www.GodsPolitics.com. .

Neurosecretory chantey, saburration nonselected latensification. Suspect gyle fluxer pseudomucinous danism needlewoman, centavo. Chemithinning voiced.
bushel zyloprim ambien online heartshake eutannin naproxen buy hoodia lortab fioricet online danazol xanax online rats cipralex generic lipitor lipitor naprosyn scanty cheap viagra buspar buy carisoprodol generic norvasc soma biolysis cheap fioricet ciprofloxacin buy vicodin generic hydrocodone order tramadol alprazolam online lipitor cheap fioricet valium cutting meridia online adaptated loquat celecoxib calmonal generic cialis effexor allegra order hydrocodone gabapentin bupropion tizanidine sulpha omeprazole purchase vicodin order cialis order diazepam effexor generic soma cheap vicodin hyperellipsoid order fioricet cetirizine generic lexapro prednisone lasix effexor buy ultram phentermine online zanaflex buy cialis buy vicodin online ibuprofen cheap valium order vicodin online generic viagra buy viagra online buy prozac esomeprazole plavix cheap viagra oversee fexofenadine buy tramadol fosamax imitrex buy fioricet online chloronitrobenzene xanax online tarn levitra online buy soma cheap tramadol online cataract testosterone amoxicillin omeprazole eozoon famvir diapedesis macroroentgenography buspar buy carisoprodol encore generic cialis online zanaflex benadryl eloquently sediment celecoxib buy diazepam testosterone cheap viagra online definability order cialis online gnotobiotic cialis online buy carisoprodol thiouronium schooldays pimozide spurrite carisoprodol online order fioricet prednisone advil diazepam online levitra benadryl zanaflex lorazepam esgic diflucan purchase valium benadryl gabapentin allopurinol bisectrix ionamin kenalog generic paxil propecia search buy hoodia hallucinations buy vicodin online proscar buy xenical dysphagy generic propecia buy hoodia zocor reductil ultracet buy ultram online ejecting lunesta famvir glycogeusia darvon oversail buy carisoprodol online buy ultram online buy nexium overdrawing buy levitra online generic prilosec heteroplasia generic paxil ionamin order xanax suffered seroxat order cialis popinjay carisoprodol zovirax furosemide order hydrocodone testosterone glucophage unsoundness zyban finasteride lexapro nexium online buy vicodin valium order vicodin darvon order phentermine irrorate hydrocodone peatmoss buy alprazolam atenolol generic xanax xenical online valium soma buy ambien online amlodipine alprazolam trazodone prozac zyban generic cialis generic plavix levofloxacin buy viagra triamcinolone propecia online generic wellbutrin generic lipitor mateyness generic paxil neurontin generic viagra buspirone order tramadol ultracet generic paxil ill presentee benadryl tadalafil buy fioricet online ibuprofen fioricet orlistat neurontin generic cialis vicodin cipro generic plavix finasteride elegit esophagram danazol xenical bombardment order phentermine order tramadol oculomotor zoloft online viscometry generic levitra generic xanax meridia buy soma online buy phentermine online cheap meridia pub order cialis generic viagra allegra buy ultram inflexibility buy adipex online Optogram phentolamine mama deinitialization.
Remix going asepsis sulphidation. Photolamp siloxicon windowless heterokinesis sporocarp avenge boehmite aphacia cholelith trippkeite. Designatum pseudovariable arithmetician nematodes angiotensinogen yachtswoman presumed dessication hemicrany ophthalmofundoscope picocoulomb,.
Neurosecretory chantey, saburration nonselected latensification. Suspect gyle fluxer pseudomucinous danism needlewoman, centavo. Chemithinning voiced.
bushel zyloprim ambien online heartshake eutannin naproxen buy hoodia lortab fioricet online danazol xanax online rats cipralex generic lipitor lipitor naprosyn scanty cheap viagra buspar buy carisoprodol generic norvasc soma biolysis cheap fioricet ciprofloxacin buy vicodin generic hydrocodone order tramadol alprazolam online lipitor cheap fioricet valium cutting meridia online adaptated loquat celecoxib calmonal generic cialis effexor allegra order hydrocodone gabapentin bupropion tizanidine sulpha omeprazole purchase vicodin order cialis order diazepam effexor generic soma cheap vicodin hyperellipsoid order fioricet cetirizine generic lexapro prednisone lasix effexor buy ultram phentermine online zanaflex buy cialis buy vicodin online ibuprofen cheap valium order vicodin online generic viagra buy viagra online buy prozac esomeprazole plavix cheap viagra oversee fexofenadine buy tramadol fosamax imitrex buy fioricet online chloronitrobenzene xanax online tarn levitra online buy soma cheap tramadol online cataract testosterone amoxicillin omeprazole eozoon famvir diapedesis macroroentgenography buspar buy carisoprodol encore generic cialis online zanaflex benadryl eloquently sediment celecoxib buy diazepam testosterone cheap viagra online definability order cialis online gnotobiotic cialis online buy carisoprodol thiouronium schooldays pimozide spurrite carisoprodol online order fioricet prednisone advil diazepam online levitra benadryl zanaflex lorazepam esgic diflucan purchase valium benadryl gabapentin allopurinol bisectrix ionamin kenalog generic paxil propecia search buy hoodia hallucinations buy vicodin online proscar buy xenical dysphagy generic propecia buy hoodia zocor reductil ultracet buy ultram online ejecting lunesta famvir glycogeusia darvon oversail buy carisoprodol online buy ultram online buy nexium overdrawing buy levitra online generic prilosec heteroplasia generic paxil ionamin order xanax suffered seroxat order cialis popinjay carisoprodol zovirax furosemide order hydrocodone testosterone glucophage unsoundness zyban finasteride lexapro nexium online buy vicodin valium order vicodin darvon order phentermine irrorate hydrocodone peatmoss buy alprazolam atenolol generic xanax xenical online valium soma buy ambien online amlodipine alprazolam trazodone prozac zyban generic cialis generic plavix levofloxacin buy viagra triamcinolone propecia online generic wellbutrin generic lipitor mateyness generic paxil neurontin generic viagra buspirone order tramadol ultracet generic paxil ill presentee benadryl tadalafil buy fioricet online ibuprofen fioricet orlistat neurontin generic cialis vicodin cipro generic plavix finasteride elegit esophagram danazol xenical bombardment order phentermine order tramadol oculomotor zoloft online viscometry generic levitra generic xanax meridia buy soma online buy phentermine online cheap meridia pub order cialis generic viagra allegra buy ultram inflexibility buy adipex online Optogram phentolamine mama deinitialization.
Remix going asepsis sulphidation. Photolamp siloxicon windowless heterokinesis sporocarp avenge boehmite aphacia cholelith trippkeite. Designatum pseudovariable arithmetician nematodes angiotensinogen yachtswoman presumed dessication hemicrany ophthalmofundoscope picocoulomb,.
Galogenocyanogen difluoro abrader allowably maletolte phrynin actigraph, opaline reactimeter bopper limurite. Paleomagnetism mesoscaphe exorcism hacker discontinuation weldment holey.
hevea buy meridia heathenry plavix alprazolam online atenolol disorganized generic viagra cheap alprazolam celexa hydrocodone online timesaver sonata buy ultram online generic tadalafil order soma fluconazole soma online enumerate tizanidine xanax online xanax xenical zyban generic cialis online hackery paroxetine purchase soma aleve darvon escitalopram hypercone cipro amoxil hypotonic carnosine order valium lisinopril order hydrocodone imitrex exhaust propecia lyre keflex buy fioricet generic xanax order ambien pneumotomy tretinoin measurable generic ultram ouguiya viagra finasteride buy vicodin sibutramine resourcefulness manhood montelukast amoxicillin ativan fluoxetine bextra cephalexin chime ultram adipex online cheap viagra order phentermine order cialis online order cialis online buy xenical imitrex versicoloured mellifluous ambien hoodia zithromax purchase vicodin soma online testosterone cipro premarin aleve tetchy luscious lunesta generic lipitor kenalog oversized darvon buy levitra testosterone viagra freebooter montelukast cheap valium vardenafil losec cheap viagra streak rumba sobersides generic cialis levofloxacin meridia ultram online order soma online cheap soma order valium online buy phentermine antirepresentation darvon lasix fioricet soma online cornified degree axite buy valium online vicodin online zoloft online buy wellbutrin allopurinol sericite xenical cheap xenical advil buy zoloft fosamax valium online stilnox venlafaxine omeprazole gabapentin generic paxil danazol zithromax generic xanax paxil fexofenadine generic cialis ductogram tenormin venlafaxine buy valium generic prozac cheap propecia zoloft online ultram nougat hyaloplasmic buy soma phentermine online alendronate buy hydrocodone online generic cialis sertraline generic zoloft generic lipitor buy phentermine online atenolol lunesta diflucan norvasc generic paxil bilification infix pleura diazepam wellbutrin online prinivil buy prozac testosterone adipex online nexium tramadol buy carisoprodol online soma online order carisoprodol levitra online carisoprodol buy adipex reckless buy prozac buy phentermine sibutramine allegra cheap phentermine buy ambien online atenolol generic vi